What are the Dangers of Soy for Men?

CPW

The dangers of soy for men are a result of the high levels of the female hormone estrogen that soy and soy-based products contain. Primarily, soy affects the quality and concentration of a male’s sperm, especially if taken in large quantities or if the subject was exposed to high levels in the womb. A recent study at Harvard University showed that there was a definite correlation between men with low sperm counts and a high intake of soy foods. The study revealed that the average sperm concentration of 80 to 120 million per millimeter of an adult male was more than halved when soy formed part of the diet. The case is more compelling in the study of obese males whose sperm levels are even lower owing to the estrogen making properties of fat tissue.

Soy is found in tofu.
Soy is found in tofu.

Scientists believe that the isoflavones (daidzein, genistein and glycitein) found in soy is to blame for poor sperm concentrations. These isoflavones act like estrogen does and they therefore inhibit the production of sperm. Moreover, Professor Lynn Fraser of King's College London has also issued warnings about the isolflavone genistein which is believed can contribute to the failure of the sperm to fertilize the egg. However, these findings were founded on test-tube based experiments and soy industry bodies have countered that the genistein found in soy-based products reacts differently to the pure form of the isoflavones that was used to conduct the research.

Soy beans.
Soy beans.

Soy is found most abundantly in foods such as soya beans, tofu, tempeh, tofu or soy sausages, bacon, burgers, soy milk, cheese, yogurt, ice cream and nuts. However, soy and soy derivatives are to be found in approximately 70% of all foods and therefore reducing intake can be difficult. For example, pork pies, breakfast cereals, mayonnaise and margarines, sausages, lasagna, beef burgers and chicken nuggets are some of the foods that rely on soy as a source of cheap protein. The soy derivative lecithin is also pervasive in the bakery and confectionary industries because of its effectiveness as an emulsifier.

Want to automatically save time and money month? Take a 2-minute quiz to find out how you can start saving up to $257/month.

Soy milk.
Soy milk.

It should be noted that soy is very much a mainstay of Asian diets and no significant side-effects have been found in these countries. However, it is salutary to bear in mind that the Asian soy diet is based largely on fermented soy products, such as miso soup and tofu; the fermentation process is thought to destroy the chemicals that are considered harmful in the above experiments.

Eating a lot of mayonnaise, which contains soy, can expose men to high levels of the female hormone, estrogen.
Eating a lot of mayonnaise, which contains soy, can expose men to high levels of the female hormone, estrogen.
Soy products contain high levels of the female hormone estrogen.
Soy products contain high levels of the female hormone estrogen.
Soy can be found in a number of packaged products such as lasagna, chicken nuggets and cereal.
Soy can be found in a number of packaged products such as lasagna, chicken nuggets and cereal.
Soy may affect the quality of a male's sperm.
Soy may affect the quality of a male's sperm.

You might also Like

Discussion Comments

anon265876

All these various reports sound like nothing more than a propaganda war between the beef/dairy industry and the soy industry battling for market share. It would be nice to get a neutral and unbiased report.

anon79353

In asian cultures they consume large amounts of sea foods. This high amount of iodine negates the effects of high soy consumption.

anon65917

I agree with previous comment of conducting serious study in Asia. The problem may not lie in the lecithin, soymilk and such... may be just the fact that it's GMO soy vs. non-GMO soy, or simply the study may be drawing the wrong conclusion as it fails to be properly set up.

I do not see asian population shrinking because they consume soy products... actually it would look it's quite the opposite.

anon60985

i am from the Philippines, and being part of asia, soy have been part of our diet, in any form, be it in tofu, milk, etc. Asian families are huge in terms of members, some have even 12 children. and most of them consume soy products almost every day.

i guess the university who did this study should also consider these facts. i would like to see another research study in which the respondents are mostly asians to validate the results.

anon41592

Question for anon39074: What new studies?

anon39074

new studies just out on this, soy is OK now.

as of july 2009

Post your comments
Login:
Forgot password?
Register: