Do Dogs Ever Feel Guilty?

Dog owners like to think that their animals actually exhibit guilt when they’ve done something wrong and are confronted with the evidence. However, researchers say that dogs don’t have the capacity to feel guilt or shame, even though people might think they look guilty or ashamed. Many studies have shown that canine brains aren’t capable of such complex feelings. Research suggests that when dogs appear sheepish, they are simply reacting to the scolding tone of your voice or your body language, and are bracing for whatever punishment they associate with those stimuli.

Personifying our pets:

  • In 2015, a Cambridge University researcher tested dogs and their owners. After the owners taught their dogs not to eat a biscuit, they left the room. A researcher then either removed the biscuit or urged the dog to eat it.

  • When the owners returned to the room and saw that the biscuit was gone, they were asked whether they thought the dog had eaten the biscuit, judging by the dog’s expression. The owners were unable to accurately identify guilt in their pets' demeanor.

  • Animal behaviorist Elaine Henley explained that dogs “don't understand they have done wrong, so can't be shamed into good behavior. Often, they are just as likely to go and do the same thing again.”

Follow wiseGEEK:

More Info: The Telegraph

Discuss this Article

Post 4

This is a one-shot study. I don't believe the conclusions are valid.

Post 3

Well, we had a couple of dogs, and when they had chewed something up or pooped in the house, they definitely hung their head, hid, avoided eye contact or otherwise looked like they clearly knew they had done something wrong, without a word being spoken!

Post 2

I'm wondering if any of these "researchers" actually have a dog?

Post 1

I enjoy reading Wisegeek every day....

Just a suggestion, but why not have some form of Star feed-back to register interest in subjects....

Mike. * * * * *

Post your comments

Post Anonymously


forgot password?



Free Widgets for your Site/Blog

Horses are responsible for more human deaths in Australia than all of the nation's venomous creatures put together.  more...
December 8 ,  1965 :  Pope Paul VI promulgated Vatican II into ecumenical law.  more...