Why is Perpetual Motion Considered to be Impossible?

science engineering

The idea of perpetual motion sounds so straightforward. An electric car powered by perpetual motion could recharge its own batteries forever, or a perpetual motion clock could automatically rewind itself for years. But there is a reason why perpetual motion machines remain in the realm of fantasy; it's the Laws of Thermodynamics. Some inventions may appear to run by perpetual motion, but they usually rely on a hidden source of external energy.

Both the First and Second Laws of Thermodynamics keep our perpetual motion car in the garage. According to one portion of the First Law, energy cannot be created or destroyed, only changed to different forms. The batteries which power an electric car only contain a fixed amount of energy. Most of this energy goes into propelling the electric motor, but some is inevitably lost through friction and the recreation of momentum after a stop. Our perpetual motion car's recharger would have to create even more energy in order to keep the batteries at full capacity. No such power generator exists, nor can one be built if the Laws of Thermodynamics are true.

The Second Law of Thermodynamics also prevents perpetual motion machines from becoming reality. Part of the Second Law states that heat energy inevitably seeks out cold areas, eventually creating a neutral temperature state called entropy. This means our proposed perpetual motion car will eventually conk out from a lack of usable heat energy. The motor casing gets hot during work, and some of that heat energy would be dissipated into the air, not back into the battery system. Since external factors such as gravity and friction would be constantly pulling on the machine, eventually all of the usable energy would be lost.

Perpetual motion machines would only be possible if a substance could be found that generated more energy than it used. Some inventors hoped that radioactive materials would prove to be useful as perpetual motion engines, but their energy is still considered finite. Magnets have also been used to power would-be perpetual motion machines, but their continued operation often requires some external energy source. Gravity is usually considered a force hostile to the cause of perpetual motion, but some inventors use gravity to their advantage when creating theoretical perpetual motion machines.

Because scientific laws and theories generally deem perpetual motion impossible, patent offices are extremely reluctant to grant patents for such machines. Proposed perpetual motion machines are the only devices which require a working model at the time of patent application. To date, no inventor has successfully submitted a working model of a true perpetual motion machine.

Related wiseGEEK articles

Category






  
  
	

		

New: Discuss this Article

Posted by: Marknelson
c27, stop using big words, they dont impress anybody.

just say that people should try to make machines MORE efficient. A catalog I read sells a earth model that spins for months after its started. but it doesnt go on forever. i think it uses a solar cell though.

Posted by: c27
By the way, let me add to the above: With the new developments and discoveries in superconductivity (frictionless magnetic bearings, superconducting motors and generators) perhaps we are closer to the realization of such machines ( Perpetual Motion Machines ) more than we realize. ( I know what you are thinking: Entropy gets in the way. But let's not forget that according to this law of entropy we are not suppose to exist either!)
Posted by: c27
I think that what the author intended to ask was: Are perpetual motion machines possible within the confines of a celestial body, ie, Earth? I say this because perpetual motion is a veritable reality. Really, when was the last time someone gave a shove to our planet in order to keep it in orbit around the sun? Now, are perpetual motion machines possible? I answer with a resounding "maybe." Why? Because just a few years back the authorities of the day were stipulating that a heavier than air machine would never fly. Today we call these machines "aircraft." Remember: The dream of yesterday is the reality of today and the hope of tomorrow.

FREE: Subscribe to wiseGEEK

 
    learn more

our strict privacy policy ensures that your email address will be safe



Written by Michael Pollick

copyright © 2003 - 2008
conjecture corporation