Why Does the US Have a Different Measurement System?

science engineering

The US measurement system is a confusing matter and still holds itself apart from the metric system employed by most other countries. There are a few exceptions. Medical and scientific fields use the metric system, and many items for trade are now measured in the International System of Units (SI), also called the metric system.

The US measurement system is based on the English system, or imperial units, though England has now long since converted to SI. However, the change to SI was not an easy passage in the mid 19th century. At first some of the British resisted the change to the SI measurement system with great force.

Legally, according to laws passed in 1988, SI became the standard measurement system for trade and commerce in the US. SI is also taught in schools at a relatively young age, but it is difficult to make the conversions.

If one initially learns the metric system, it is far easier. Everything is constructed on a base ten approach, so conversion from centimeters to meters is a simple matter. Conversely, the US measurement system is often problematic. It is not consistent in its measurements so conversion is quite challenging.

For example, twelve inches equal a foot, but eight (liquid) ounces equal a cup. Sixteen (weight) ounces equal a pound, but three feet equal a yard. Children must memorize quite a bit to perform appropriate conversions.

Since children usually first learn to measure by inches, the metric system cannot be properly taught until multiplication skills are mastered. An inch converts to 2.54 centimeters, thus anything above ten inches involves two-digit multiplication. This is a skill not mastered by most students until the later part of third or even fourth grade.

If, conversely, the metric measurement system were adopted immediately, children would probably learn it just as quickly as they learn the US system. However, since real-life examples are often included in teaching, this would be difficult to do. If one buys a TV, he or she buys a 20-inch screen, not a 50.8-cm screen. If one purchases milk, the choice is a quart, a pint or a gallon, not a measurement in liters (L) or milliliters (mL).

In general, consumer products still adhere to the US measurement system, as well as American cookbooks, so these figures must be known. Essentially, this means US children must learn two measurement systems, and unless they plan to export items, or become doctors or scientists, they may never fully master SI.

Unless the US government insists on the conversion in products, and teaching in the metric system, it is likely that the US will retain their own measurement system. However, with increasing globalization it makes sense to consider that much of the world, and especially the scientific world, relies on the metric system. Our ability to learn it makes us have that much more in common with our fellow countries.

Related wiseGEEK articles

Category

wiseGEEK features

Subscribe to wiseGEEK


4
I disagree. While the American system is harder to understand, I have memorized many of the conversions and can tell you that a mile is 5,280 feet, 16 ounces is a pound and the like. The metric system, on the other hand, while simpler, is different to me and I prefer to go with what I already know. In studying the system in science I get all confused and must turn to a chart of the measurements. Perhaps I have not studied it enough, or perhaps I just don't like change which is highly probable, but I like the standard system better than the metric system. I hope the US continues using it.
- anon47043
3
I started school learning imperial measurements in NZ; the metric system was introduced mid way through. The metric system is a lot more logical and therefore easier to learn than the imperial (or standard) system so people should not be reluctant to embrace it. At nearly 50 I still calculate kg to lbs and miles to km in my head. It is really not difficult to make the transition.
- anon36980

FREE: Subscribe to wiseGEEK

 
    learn more

our strict privacy policy ensures that your email address will be safe



Written by Tricia Ellis-Christensen
Last Modified: 30 September 2009

copyright © 2003 - 2009
conjecture corporation