Why Do Some People Have Trouble Showing Affection?

health wellness

There are many theories on why people have trouble showing affection, and also cultural studies on how different groups show affection. Medical researchers can focus on specific groups that have an extraordinarily difficult time with any displays of affection, such as autistic children, or children and adults with varied degrees of autism based disorders. A significant problem with most of these studies and theories is that affection itself is a tricky thing to define.

Is affection latching on to a husband or wife with a big sloppy kiss, hugging your children or telling your parents you love them? Is affection remembering anniversaries, picking out thoughtful gifts, really listening to another person, or patting your dog on the head? Our different definitions of what constitutes affectionate behavior may make it very challenging to explain why some people have trouble showing affection; what appears to be trouble to one person may seem like a reasonable level of affection to another person. For the purposes of this article, let’s consider affection as small or large physical gestures that convey emotion, a hug, caress, kiss, a pat on the shoulder, et cetera.

Some theories suggest that such gestures of affection are often determined by our degree of nurturance as children. In families or cultures where affection is common, people will more commonly show affection. Others also suggest a gender difference, especially in many Western cultures, between showing affection to boys and girls. Girls may receive more affection than boys, especially when they are emotionally distressed. Boys, alternately, may be told when they seek affection, such as when they are injured, to toughen up. Even though we think we’ve shed these gender differences, evidence to the contrary is available in a variety of studies; we are still harder on boys.

This can matter a lot when boys and girls grow up, because girls will expect a higher degree of affection than boys, who have been nurtured to give less. Women will claim their husbands have trouble showing affection, and men may actually complain that their wives show too much. Studies on lesbian and gay couples include some interesting reveals on affectionate behaviors on same sex couples. By in large, lesbian couples tend to give and show more affection than do gay male couples, which can argue the case that men have been taught to be less affectionate. There are certainly exceptions and numerous wonderfully affectionate males, and less affectionate females.

There are other reasons why people may have difficulty showing affection. People who have experienced sexual or physical abuse may find it very difficult to receive or give affection, even very simple things like a caress or hug. For these folks, touching itself has become a violation of self, and they don’t want to receive touching, or give it and possibly be considered as abusers too.

More simply, some children are just less acclimatized to affection than others. Parents can love their children but have trouble showing affection to each other or to children. This doesn’t mean that these parents love their children less; it simply means that physical affection is expressed less frequently in a home. Generally what you’re shown as a kid tends to have an influence on adult behavior; the old nurture argument, and certainly the difference in cultural views of affection come into play.

With so much today being shown to have a genetic basis, many people question whether trouble showing affection may be in the genes. Research on autism, though genetic basis for this condition has not been clearly established, clearly shows that many of these children are completely cut off in their ability to show affection. Some make the leap and say some people may simply be “wired” to be less affectionate than others. Strong cultural precepts on displays of affection, and nurturing may tend to bring out what is already genetically predetermined. Even the most affectionate parents, may not produce the most affectionate children if there is a genetic factor determining a lesser degree of affection.

Can you fix such a problem? There are certainly many mental health professionals and marriage and family counselors that believe you can, when the condition is not medical. People may be able to learn to show affection, though at first it may seem unnatural or forced. For those with trouble showing affection, especially when this becomes a problem in couple relationships or in parenting, it may be worthwhile to get through this awkward phase to improve relationships. This may be very true when other parties in relationships are unhappy with the level of affection they receive.

Related wiseGEEK articles

Category





  
  
  
	

		

New: Discuss this Article

Posted by: WiltedDaisy
My dear girls, I am a trained counsellor myself!! I am having counselling myself, however it would make my husband angry to know that I am doing so as he doesn't want anyone to know, and again it comes back always to being my fault anyway.

My options are : (1) stay and continue to wilt (2) tell him to leave (3) leave myself.

Fortunately there are no children to consider in this matter.

Considering he also verbally abuses me, threatens me, mind, never physically, so far I've put up with it. I know, girls, this is a victim mentality, but I grew up in such a situation, so it is familiar to me. I don't want a show-down while things are peaceful/boring, I feel I must wait until he becomes abusive again and then WHAM from me verbally. I will tell him to get out, get counselling and not to come back until he has sorted himself out. Did you know that to deny / withhold affection is also sexual abuse? (as it is one of the most basic human needs). At least I have a very supportive network around me, which is buoying me.

Thanks for your comments. I guess it all boils down to what my personal threshold of suffering limits are, doesn't it?

Posted by: WGwriter
Wilted Daisy,

My next thought would be get counseling for you. You may be facing some major decisions and can probably use support and help figuring out what to do with your life. Standard advice on the hubbies who won't get counseling, is to get counseling for yourself to find out whether or not this is a marriage you can sustain, and what your options are in a marriage. As you move through that process, sometimes hubbies get interested, and you might ask if he will attend a few sessions for your sake, to improve your mental health-- sometime after you start.

If it's difficult to afford, look at some of the clinics where educated counselors work under supervision to fulfill their hours requirements to get their licenses. Many of these therapists are excellent, and they work under supervision of trained and licensed therapists. They often offer low cost and sliding scale fees.

Again, I know this is extremely difficult, and this is just girl to girl advice, not WG advice. Please keep us posted on how you are doing.

Tricia C.

Posted by: WiltedDaisy
Dear WGwriter, Husband is typical male who will not seek therapy, as everything with affection is my fault. Prayer has not helped so far either.
Posted by: WGwriter
Dear WiltedDaisy, I am so sorry for your situation and for your husband's, who must see your attempts at showing affection as possibly violating. Is there any way your husband will consider therapy? Would he go with you to a therapist jointly for couples counseling? This is just straight advice, gal to gal, but I would strongly suggest you ask him to see a therapist with you if he is willing. Pick a male therapist, if you think he will be more comfortable talking to a guy than a woman. This may be a long term issue, and a lot depends on his willingness to work the process of recovery from abuse.

Unfortunately, we seldom cure the ones we love, unless they want to be changed or "cured." Best of luck to you.

Posted by: WiltedDaisy
My husband was in that unenviable position of being "interfered with" as a child, and not being able to show me affection when I need it, seeing me as "pathetic" in needing it, has brought me to the end of my ability to stay married to him. He doesn't see his attitude as a problem. I thought that by loving him a cure would be effected - naive me. Is there anything that can be done to "open" him up? I am at the threshold of leaving..

FREE: Subscribe to wiseGEEK

 
    learn more

our strict privacy policy ensures that your email address will be safe



Written by Tricia Ellis-Christensen

copyright © 2003 - 2008
conjecture corporation