Why Didn't Communism Work in Eastern Europe?

define

Communism failed in Eastern European countries for the same reason it routinely fails in others — there's no money in it, at least not for the people who need it most. While the economic system known as communism may have worked well on paper, the political form of communism forced on Eastern European countries brought little more than oppression and hardship to the working class citizens it exploited. Many of the Eastern European governments were puppet regimes handpicked by Communist Party leaders working remotely from Russia. Communications between Russia and its Eastern European satellites were rarely two-way streets.

One main reason why communism failed in Eastern Europe was human nature. Under economic communism, control over production is supposed to be given to the workers, ostensibly with the guidance and oversight of a strong central State. Communist farmers who produced corn, for instance, would donate the vast majority of their yearly crops to the government. In exchange, the government would provide each farmer with a supply of corn for personal use, along with a portion of all the other goods produced by other self-controlled communes. Unfortunately, the timely distribution of goods was severely hampered by corruption and mismanagement, a common problem in Communist countries.

When any form of government, whether capitalist or communist, fails to meet the basic needs of its people, civil unrest is bound to follow. This was especially the case in Eastern Europe after World War II. Tyrannical Communist leaders such as Joseph Stalin used economic communism as a means to support their own agendas, while millions of civilians were systematically imprisoned or summarily executed. The message to Eastern European countries became clear — dissension would simply not be tolerated. During the 1950s and 1960s, country after country in Eastern Europe began to revolt against the oppressive Soviet system that sought to keep them enslaved to a corrupt form of political communism.

By the time of the Soviet Union's disintegration in 1991, economic communism was fast becoming a failed experiment in the eyes of the Western world. Many collective companies in Eastern European companies discovered the advantages of a free market society, including the right to deal directly with buyers. Under economic communism, there were very few incentives offered to more industrious workers. The idea of profit through increased production proved to be one of the strongest arguments against communism, and many Eastern European countries were eager to move towards a freer economic system.

Some historians credit former Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev with implementing the policies leading to the end of communism in Eastern Europe. Gorbachev's policy of glasnost, meaning openness, allowed eastern European countries the freedom to replace Moscow-controlled governments with local leaders. Once free of Soviet rule, the individual countries were free to create their own economic systems, many of which still retain some elements of economic communism while embracing capitalism and socialism as well.

Related wiseGEEK articles

Category

wiseGEEK features

Subscribe to wiseGEEK


5
Economic Communism didn't fail; it was never implemented. that which called itself communist or socialist in eastern Europe was little more than a thinly veiled oligarchy. The ideas of Marx and Engels were a descriptive teleological model of economic development. It was not meant as a government form. Sadly some rebels without a cause, and a bare modicum of education, shanghaied the entire ideology to create self-serving dictatorships.
- anon53346
4
"Marx was a brilliant thinker" but he was wrong. The bottom line is Communism, socialism and central planning do not work. Capitalism does!
- anon36189
3
Communism didn't work in east europe for the same reason it didn't work in other countries... when incentives are removed, people don't produce.

Marx was a brilliant thinker, but I think he didn't forsee that people were not advanced enough (and probably cannot become "advanced" enough) to operate solely for the greater good. People are generally selfish, and need selfish motivations to be especially productive.

You can call that sad, and perhaps it is, but it is how we operate as a species, and no ideology can overcome that.

- concordski
2
communism was imposed on the peoples of eastern europe, and i don't think that enough of the population were proponents of the system. a sufficient percentage of the population needs to be "on-board" if a political system even has a chance.

this begs the question whether communism could work anywhere, but because of the low buy-in, i don't think it ever had a feasible chance in eastern europe.

- concordski
1
It is the dissolution of the Warsaw Pact in 1991, that allowed the Eastern European countries to create their own economic systems.
- frankjoseph

FREE: Subscribe to wiseGEEK

 
    learn more

our strict privacy policy ensures that your email address will be safe



Written by Michael Pollick
Last Modified: 20 November 2009

copyright © 2003 - 2009
conjecture corporation