Which are the Best Dog Breeds For a Guard Dog?

animals environment

For centuries, dogs have served as guardians of their owners' property, whether it be family members, homes, livestock or land. While most dogs do this naturally, some dog breeds are especially inclined towards this task. Guarding duty varies in the level of protection provided by dogs, such as being watchdogs or alarm dogs, guard dogs, and attack dogs.

Watchdogs or alarm dogs simply warn their owners by barking vigorously when anything out of the ordinary occurs, such as strangers who are passing by too close to the vicinity of the owners' homes. Guard dogs go one step further by having the ability to restrain intruders and attacking upon the instructions of their owners. Attack dogs are more vicious, and are trained to attack intruders on sight.

While watchdogs may provide sufficient warning to their owners, they usually do not have the ability to guard or act against an intruder. Meanwhile, attack dogs can become unsafe if not properly trained or handled. Guard dogs offer a comfortable medium between the two types, and are suitable for those who wish to protect their homes without the risk of injuring or killing anyone, even intruders.

There are many dog breeds that can be trained as guard dogs, but these are the most common ones used for their natural guarding ability:

1. Rottweiler

Rottweilers make great guard dogs and family companions. Their protective instincts ensure their immediate action once a family or 'pack' member is threatened by an intruder or a dangerous action. Massive in size, these dogs grow to a height of 24 to 27 inches (61 to 69 cm) and weigh between 93 to 110 pounds (42 to 50 kg).

Rottweilers are good guard dogs because of their alertness and wait-and-see attitude. They do not usually bark unnecessarily until and unless they see any harm is about to come upon their owners or the territory that they are guarding. They are quick learners but nevertheless, need firm handling and discipline due to their strong-willed nature.

2. Doberman

Standing tall at a height between 24 to 28 inches (61 to 71 cm) and weighing anywhere from 71 to 100 pounds (32 to 45 kg), Dobermans are well-known for their fierce temperament, making them excellent guard dogs. These dogs are increasingly being used in both the military and police force because of their obedience, intelligence, highly trainable attitude and ability to handle human assailants. Despite their ferocious reputation, Dobermans are actually loving and affectionate pets, willing to do anything for their owners.

3. German Shepherd

German Shepherds have been termed by some as one of the best guard dogs and family companion. Their gentle nature, especially with children, should not be misconstrued as a lack of capability to be fierce when necessary. Highly intelligent, these dogs are obedient and are able to attack and release on command. German Shepherds are known for their courage and protectiveness when it comes to their owners. However, because of their affection and dependence on their owners, German Shepherds are prone to separation anxiety, even if left alone for a few hours.

4. Bull Mastiff

Bull Mastiffs are crossbreeds composed of 60% Mastiff and 40% Bulldog. Their appearance alone is intimidating. These dogs are tall, standing at a height between 25 and 27 inches (63 and 69 cm), and heavy, weighing from 110 to 130 pounds (50 to 60 kg). Wonderful guard dogs, Bull Mastiffs usually knock intruders down and stand above them, baring their teeth and growling threateningly.

Because of their sheer size, Bull Mastiffs also serve as guard dogs by preventing aggressors from moving past them. These dogs are fiercely loyal to their people and regard strangers warily. Hence, early socialization is crucial to ensure that Bull Mastiffs do not become aggressive against people they do not know.

Guard dogs are trained to protect their owners against intruders and aggression. Yet, they may have a tendency to become overprotective, even with strangers who cause no harm or threat. Owners should therefore ensure sufficient training and socialization of their guard dogs in order to prevent occurrences such as unwarranted domineering behavior, bites and attacks.

Related wiseGEEK articles

Category

wiseGEEK features

Subscribe to wiseGEEK


12
Fila Brasileiro! Hands down, the best guard dog. I have had shepherds, (both German and anatolian) as well as a Cane Corso.

But a Fila is second to none. A 170-pound dog who can run 35 mph and dislikes everyone.

Read up on the breed and you will understand what I am talking about. They make a pit bull look like a hamster!

- anon53570
11
anon39906 - Anatolian Shepards are superior guard dogs that will guard and protect any person or animal (cats, ducks, sheep, chickens, etc.) that it considers its family. Good luck!
- anon48320
10
I have a mastiff dog. It is about 4 and-a-half months old. It is friendly to strangers. What should I do?
- anon45452
9
one of the previous readers was accurate when highlighting other guardian breeds, but certain guardian dogs are better than others depending on the situation. A kangal, cacausian ovck, tibetan mastiff are all good and probably better than most of our familiar guard dogs. Although I am a huge fan of the bouvier as a family protector here are a few in the top tier second to none: tosa, borboel, spanish mastiff, antolian shepherd, english mastiff, fila, and presa cana. The Russian breeds would probably be mingled in there as well.
- anon42661
8
Hello. Unfortunately, when I see a topic about best guarding breeds, or something like that, I find on and on, the same answer: rott, doberman, bull mastiff, in some occasions pit, and now you can see, the usual breeds. Seeing that makes me sad, especially since I'm a breeder of another guarding breed, and have friends with other good guardian breeds. I must say, i respect and recognize the goods of the rotts, dobermans, etc. but there are some other breeds that make these look infantile. Caucasian Ovcharka (the one I breed), Central Asian Ovtcharka, Moscow Watchdog, Kangal, Tibetan Mastiff, and also some known breeds, Cane Corso, Tosa Inu. Really hope you can use the informations, and hope after seeing my post, research the breeds I mentioned, and see the difference. Good luck.
- anon42013
7
does anyone know dogs that would be great guard dogs but gentle with chickens and cats ducks and to us?
- anon39906
6
We also live on three acres in the country. We own a German Shepherd - raised her from a puppy. We do not have a fence around our property. She knows her boundaries and is protective of her territory, yet she is great with children. She can be aggressive toward other dogs that may wander into our yard, however, but that's why we got her. She is protecting the kids, the house, etc. If you decide on a German Shepherd, make sure they get plenty of time to run & play outdoors. If you drain their excess energy / anxiety, they are less likely to arbitrarily attack. I recommend a female, purebred German Shepherd.
- anon36998
4
bigmetal-Old English Mastiffs are great with children except they may knock them down because of their size. They are great guard dogs and won't bite unless owners are in danger. They much rather keep strangers at bay but if they ascend closer they will knock them down with no problem. Males can reach over 200 Ib. Females a tad smaller usually 180. Have fun finding a dog!
- anon30382
3
This information is very interesting on the particular breeds. I have 3 acres on which I plan to raise a few farm animals such as chickens and maybe a pig or goat. I could put the farm animals in crossfencing so that the dog would not harm them. But I would like the dog to protect them against other predators. Which breed would be the best as far as not running off my property? I don't want to tie a dog outside and the property is all enclosed in horse fencing, but a dog could go through it.

I know Shelties are really good about learning to not go off your property, but they aren't exactly good guard dogs. Also, I have young grandchildren who will be playing in the area with the dog. So, it has to be safe for them. I would plan to socialize early and often with them. Thanks so much!

- gormetlady
2
I've had all kinds of dogs before, but the best one of all has been a German Shepherd. He was great with kids and enjoyed playing games with them or just lying close to them and keeping watch while they played. He was a great family dog and smart to boot! I have been wanting to get another one for my girls who are 3 and 6.
- anon12785
1
what would be the best breed that was not only a great guard dog, but a good family dog as well...one that is good with kids? we had a german shepard growing up that was a phenomenal guard dog, and took really good care of us kids too. she was very good with kids, but i've heard that german shepards aren't always the best with children. any suggestions?
- bigmetal

FREE: Subscribe to wiseGEEK

 
    learn more

our strict privacy policy ensures that your email address will be safe



Written by Aniza Pourtauborde
Last Modified: 22 November 2009

copyright © 2003 - 2009
conjecture corporation