Transference is a term first used by Sigmund Freud to describe a process in analysis or therapy. Freud noted that many of his patients seemed at some point to begin to place certain feelings, like romantic love or parental love, onto the therapist. When this process occurred the therapist could use this position to help restore the client to more normal feelings by responding in ways unlike that of the person upon which the original feelings were based.
For example, a child who has been severely abused by a parent, or even simply neglected, may express transference by viewing the therapist as parent. However, because the child expects this role to be negatively charged and harmful, recovery of abuse may be possible when the therapist is neither abusive nor neglectful. Instead the therapist uses this transference to provide what the parent did not provide, a stable and accepting relationship in which the client is very important.
The therapist as parent in this type of transference may have to endure some pretty strong anger from the patient. This is in part helpful because it allows the child to express feelings that were too dangerous to express in an abusive or neglectful setting. Once these feelings of anger and grief are expressed, the patient often feels a relief, as if he or she had actually confronted his own parents.
Most commonly, transference is of a romantic nature. This does not have to be limited to relationships between client and therapists of different sexes. It is also not an indication of homosexuality, although a client with a same sex therapist may be terribly confused regarding romantic feelings toward one of the same sex.
In these cases, however, the therapist simply represents the people in the client’s life who should love him or her. The role of lover is projected onto the therapist because the therapist is usually the only person in a client’s life who is completely invested in the client, and views the client without judgment or agenda.
It can be quite difficult to discuss feelings of a romantic nature with a therapist. However, the therapist is usually aware of such feelings whether or not they are discussed. Discussion can prove to be healing and helpful, and ultimately move the client out of the transference state into a place where such feelings might be relocated back to a spouse or partner.
There is some inherent danger in transference to both client and therapist. Some therapists may transfer their own feelings onto a client. Where romantic feelings for a therapist are involved, the client would generally do anything a therapist asks, including any sexual behavior. This is strictly illegal, but there are abuses of laws protecting clients. Similar laws apply to others who might be subject to transference, such as members of the clergy, teachers and those in other medical fields.
It is important to recognize transference as a normal stage of therapy. However, if a therapist appears to reciprocate romantic feelings, engage in touching of a sexual nature or attempt to initiate a sexual relationship, this therapist is no longer of help and should be reported as in violation of the many laws guarding against such. In this case, the therapist does considerable harm to patients.
In most cases, however, the therapist, or advisor of any nature is fully apprised of laws and honors them. The therapist can use the transference stage of therapy to help a patient establish a more appropriate view of significant relationships with romantic partners or family members. The client should not feel guilty for having these feelings, though they are often confusing and difficult. Particularly when one is married they may seem unfaithful or go against marriage vows.
It helps to remember that these feelings are those one has or wishes to have with a spouse or partner. Such feelings have undergone a temporary relocation that can ultimately benefit romantic relationships. Discussion of these feelings may be highly embarrassing, but may also be a tool for reaching an excellent state of mental health in regard to relationships with significant people in one’s life.
I don't doubt that there's value that comes out of transference, but anyone who's suffered through a serious romantic transference knows that at its worst, it feels like a sick joke that is played on vulnerable, sensitive, mostly female patients by older, powerful, mostly male therapists, although it is certainly not limited to this group exclusively.
The pain is torturous and the decision to expose your innermost feelings to the object of your passion, without fully understanding it or how your therapist will handle it, is difficult and heart-wrenching.
I wonder if those therapists who are flattered by the transference and encourage it, who ignore it, or who terminate because they don't want to deal with it, realize that they may be setting up their patients for many, many years of suffering. Why there is no requirement to forewarn potential patients through pre-therapy discussion or informed consent only reaffirms my suspicion that romantic transference either is not taken seriously or is viewed with disdain by the mental health community.
- anon60314
20
i think transference is a nice legal term for horrible, illegal behavior.
- anon52603
19
mbooker, "It would be terribly embarrassing to talk with her about it. Don't know if I could do that. Could I talk around it in some way?"
MBooker, hold your breath, and throw it out on the table. That's the best way to do therapy. If your therapist is experienced there is nothing (s)he hasn't heard before including "I'm in love with you" and "I want to kill you". Just go for it.
- anon50878
18
I am in therapy with a wonderful, reputable therapist who I trust. I'm just having these incredibly strong transference (I guess) feelings, although she doesn't remind me of my mother, husband, or anyone else in my life. They have become painful, and because of the intensity, they make me want to quit the work we're doing. I don't think that would really be best to do, but I don't know what to do. It would be terribly embarrassing to talk with her about it. Don't know if I could do that. Could I talk around it in some way?
- mbooker
17
I've finally found a therapist who I trusted and after afew short months she's leaving! any suggestions. Rose
- anon37728
16
Sounds like some people out there have experienced some stuff in therapy that is somewhat unethical. Please do not generalise that to all therapy though.
Transference is a phenomenon characterised by unconscious redirection of feelings and attitudes that were originally associated with important figures (parents, siblings, etc) in one's early life and often people temporarily substitute the therapist for the object of desire. Many approaches to therapy recognise the importance of identifying peoples' transference reactions to their therapist. Most commonly transference is of a romantic nature however mostly the therapist represents the people in a persons' life who should love them. Therapists are a secure base and for some people they have never experienced that before. A disussion in therapy can be helpful and healing and assist the person to a state where those feelings are relocated back to their partner, parent ect.
- anon37068
15
I have been in therapy for 5 months with my therapist and believe that I am going through transference now. should I tell him? He is my fifth therapist and the only therapist that I have gotten help from.
- anon36945
14
Nearly 20 years ago a therapist created dependency and transference in me, but I came to my senses five years later. However, my life had been ruined. The ensuing years have seen no change in me: I still suffer as a result of him. I beat myself up every day when I think how stupid and naive I was. All that I held dear was lost, because of him. I suffer every day of my life for my stupidity in allowing it to happen. But I was ill and it should never have happened - he was the one supposed to be looking after me. Please don't allow this to happen to you. If you're in the throws of transference please stop immediately before it all becomes too much for you to bear, as it has been for me.
- anon31254
13
My younger brother and sister are both abusing me regarding 'incidents' that happened to them when they were kids - that I was totally unaware of. This was 40 years ago and I am now their target where I am at fault for everything that was said to them by I think my father (who passed away 9 years ago). They are carrying around this emotional baggage making it difficult for me to even talk with them on the phone because I continue to get blamed for things I knew nothing about.
I don't know how to begin to straighten this mess out. And now I'm accused of doing things they don't approve of ... things I like ... just because of their anger.
Now I feel like a victim but as some of the symptoms of this state, that the perpetrators of this transference seem to blow up, vent and say awful things and make all these accusations, and then seem to conveniently forget they said this crap once the verbal damage has been done and people are upset. I'm very upset over these actions because I had nothing to to with them.
So ... how do you respond to this bad behavior? And is there some kind of treatment these two should seek to get the anger out of their system and to stop directing it at me and direct it at some other target?
- anon25607
12
I do not get what you mean when you say "you suffered transference"?? Does that mean you had a relationship with your therapist? or that you loved your therapist and they did not help you take a deeper look at that in the therapy?
I understand in transference work it is essential that the focus be on taking responsibility for your own feelings and looking into the repeated patterns in your life where these same feelings have occurred which in turn helps to change the unconsciousness and victim nature of the patterns.
While not all therapists are great at doing this work, I am sure there are some who take advantage of clients and this should surely be reported. Saying that you were dropped when the money ran out, well, I don't know any professionals who would do free therapy- so I can understand having to end sessions if the client cannot pay.
- anon23422
11
I want to ask questions, but I am new to computer conversation, or to any kind of conversing. I do want others input and I do have questions. I fear my friends would not be able to relate, so I would like to try this style of connecting.
- anon21799
10
Even with a good therapist, and even if no boundaries are crossed, and even if the transference is dealt with and used to benefit the therapy, you have to admit this is a very painful process. I think it's cruel. That is not to say that aren't huge benefits to entering a good therapy relationship. I've been in one. I've made tremendous strides. My gripe is with romantic transferences, and the pain they cause. A big red flag should go up when it happens, because there will always be trouble ahead.
- Josie
9
The comments here are very poignant, and I do think it is fully inappropriate for a therapist to express feelings of love back to a patient. This is one way of really messing with someone's mind. Many patients have strong feelings for therapists and when properly addressed these feelings can result in deeper and better therapy. The big deal is they have to be properly addressed with the therapist fully aware of boundaries. These feelings are no joke and they can be hard, but they can also be extremely valuable to therapy.
Much depends on how it is handled by the therapist. I think there are many competent and exceptional therapists who know how to handle this well, and are particularly concerned by the delicate nature of the client's psyche when undergoing transference. This should never be abused and I would say in most cases of therapy it isn't. These experiences mentioned here, say that it is from time to time, which isn't good. I don't think they're representative of the whole mental health profession, and I don't think they should be used to discourage others from entering therapy.
Tricia E-C
- WGwriter
8
I'll try to post one more time, with one more thought. I've been in the same situation. Very painful. Don't let them get away with it. Get the courage to bring it to their attention and work it out, or you'll carry it forever, and they'll go their merry ways. "Transference" is their excuse for falling in love. They need a convenient term for it. They need to be made responsible for the messes they cause.
- Josie
6
same as rita, only ours was for 7 years rather than two, we were dropped from a great height like a hot potato and don't know when the pieces are ever gonna be put together again. It all started of great, but as rita says when it got too much for them...........bye bye moi!
- anon12829
5
transference is not all bad if in the right context. it is truly a long process but a worthy one if you have the right therapist involved
- anon11652
4
Speaking from someone who has suffered transference for the last two years, it is the single most painful experience of my entire life and I would urge those thinking about entering into therapy to consider the consequences very seriously before you embark on it.
My life has been ruined, destroyed beyond repair by a therapist who created dependency and transference and then dropped me when it became to much for them to handle and the money ran out.
This is not something that I would wish on my worst enemy.