The life of Edgar Allan Poe was as strange and dark as the tales he penned, so it would seem only appropriate that his afterlife holds mysteries as well. Poe, a renowned poet and writer in the American Romantic and Gothic styles, was born on 19 January 1809. A tragic life followed, concluding with his untimely death at the age of 40 on 7 October 1849. Not only were the cause and circumstances of his death mysterious and cryptic, but the events that followed are as well.

In 1949, 100 years after the death of the prolific writer, a figure clad in black appeared at the Edgar Allan Poe grave in Baltimore on the date of the writer's birthday. The figure, dubbed later as the “Poe Toaster,” raised a glass of cognac in tribute to the dead poet, and proceeded to leave three red roses and a half bottle of cognac on Edgar Allan Poe's grave. This was the beginning of an annual tribute to Edgar Allan Poe, which has continued ever since.

Little is known about the identity of the Poe Toaster. The figure is male, clad in black and carries a silver-tipped cane. The Poe Toaster always shows up in the early morning hours of the Edgar Allan Poe anniversary, and always performs the same ritual. While this has been observed on numerous occasions, the Poe Toaster is rarely photographed, and often is allowed to perform his tribute undisturbed.

In addition to leaving the three roses and liquor, on occasion the Poe Toaster has left notes expressing various sentiments. Some have been simple tributes to Edgar Allan Poe, but in 1999 a note was left stating that the original Poe Toaster had passed away the previous year and that the tradition would continue by way of “a son.” The new Poe Toaster has caused contention among followers of the event, due in part because the notes he left in subsequent years stated controversial opinions. In 2006, because of these statements, a group of angry fans tried unsuccessfully to accost the Poe Toaster as he made his annual tribute.

The controversy continued over the identity of the Poe Toaster in August 2007, when Sam Porpora, historian for the Westminster Church and burial grounds where Edgar Allan Poe is interred, claimed that he had started the Poe Toaster tradition in 1967. Despite Sam Porpora's claim, the earliest newspaper mention of the Poe Toaster dates to 1950 and disproves his statement. The Edgar Allan Poe Society renounced the historian's claim, and little else was said of his story.

For the next two years, attendance at the Poe Toaster event surged, according to the Edgar Allan Poe Society. The society not only preserves the memory of Edgar Allan Poe, but has in its possession several of the gifts left behind by the mysterious Poe Toaster, whose identity remains a mystery. The 200th anniversary of Edgar Allan Poe's birth was marked in 2009. Despite the landmark occasion, the Poe Toaster did not leave a note, but continued the tradition by leaving three roses and a bottle of cognac at the gravesite.