Category: 

What Is the Model Penal Code?

Article Details
  • Written By: Lainie Petersen
  • Edited By: Jenn Walker
  • Last Modified Date: 06 April 2014
  • Copyright Protected:
    2003-2014
    Conjecture Corporation
  • Print this Article
Free Widgets for your Site/Blog
Artists tend to grow up in wealthier households than doctors.  more...

April 24 ,  2005 :  The world's first cloned dog was born.  more...

The Model Penal Code is a document designed as model for state criminal law in the United States. This statutory text, published by the The American Law Institute (ALI) in 1962, was an an attempt to encourage the standardization of criminal law across the states. The ALI, a non-governmental professional association for judges, lawyers and scholars, prepared its report after reviewing the penal laws in several states. It developed its recommendations after recognizing that criminal law in many states was not based on a central guiding philosophy; it was being developed spontaneously in response to various crimes as they were committed and caught public attention.

Most criminal law in the United States is a matter of state, not federal, law. The Model Penal Code was published with the hopes of influencing state legislatures to adopt a cohesive approach to the establishment of penal law. The code advocated the use of certain broad concepts, such as a criminal's state of mind, or mens rea, in determining the legal status of a crime and the severity of punishment. Under this principle, crimes committed with malicious intent are generally considered more serious than crimes that are the result of negligence or accident. The punishment for a crime, therefore, would differ depending on the perpetrator's thinking, even if the outcome was the same.

Ad

The Model Penal Code offers guidelines for arrest as well. For example, the code puts forward the principle that unless an act is actually forbidden in law, it should be considered legal. People should not be arrested and prosecuted for crimes that are not clearly defined, by law, as illegal.

The influence of the code on state criminal law has been mixed. State legislatures have adopted some aspects of the code and rejected others. For example, while the Modern Penal Code opposes the principle that a death that occurs in the course of a felony must be considered murder, this so-called felony murder rule remains the law in most of the United States.

It should also be noted that some of the Model Penal Code became outdated in its approach to certain crimes. The original code never mentioned drug offenses and did not criminalize marital rape. The ALI has also recognized that some of the code's prescriptions may be unworkable. For example, in 2009, the ALI voted to disavow its suggestions for the implementation of capital punishment, noting that it is impossible to reconcile the death penalty with oppressive social systems that inhibit fair sentencing.

Ad

Discuss this Article

jonrss
Post 3

Its interesting that this group took a stand against capital punishment. The tide seems to be shifting away from this brutal practice and this is just more evidence of how wrong it is. This is a group whose sole mission is to create the most effective legal system in the world. It must serve defendants, plaintiffs and citizens in equal measure. If a group like this argues against the death penalty I don't know how any legal scholar could support it.

whiteplane
Post 2

This sounds like another frustrating example of the way that good ideas get ignored. What state would not want to deal with prisoners in the most efficient, humane and effective way possible? Doesn't logic tell us that over the long run this will be the cheapest, easiest and most moral course possible.

It is not as if this document was made by a biased panel trying to advance an agenda. As near as I can tell this is a well reasoned document that reflects the consensus of industry professionals. These are clearly good ideas. If only people didn't have such thick heads we could make a lot of progress in this country.

gravois
Post 1

I would be very interested in reading this document. We hear so many stories about the wild variety that exist in sentencing, prison conditions, recidivism rates and police procedures. In some states things seem to go well and in others they have been a disaster for years.

If there were national standards regarding the treatment of prisoners and there stay in jail I think it would go a long ways towards correcting this imbalance. The treatment of prisoners is easy to overlook or neglect but they deserve just, equal and humane treatment like anyone else.

Post your comments

Post Anonymously

Login

username
password
forgot password?

Register

username
password
confirm
email