What is the Difference Between NTSC and PAL?

technology gadgets

Some Americans may have sent video home movies to a European relative, only to discover that the images are scrambled and the sound quality is very poor. This is caused by a major difference in broadcast formats used by the United States and many other countries. The United States favors a format called NTSC, which is short for National Television Standards Committee, while Europe, Australia and parts of Asia use a competing format called PAL, or Phase Alternating Line.

Most of us would not be able to recognize the difference between NTSC and PAL, but then again most of us aren't television broadcast engineers. The differences really start with the electrical power system behind the transmissions. In the United States and other countries, electrical power is generated at 60 hertz, so for technical reasons the NTSC signal is also sent out at 60 'fields' per second. Since most televisions use an interlaced system, this means that 30 lines of the image are sent out, followed by the alternating 30 lines. This line alternation happens so fast that it becomes undetectable, much like a film running through a projector. The result for an NTSC television is 30 frames of a complete image appearing every second.

Since Europe uses a 50 hertz power supply, the equivalent PAL lines go out at 50 fields per second, or 25 alternating lines. PAL televisions only produce 25 complete frames per second, which can cause some problems with the proper display of motion. Think of it as the 'silent movie effect', in which the actors seem to move a little faster because there are fewer frames showing movement. If a PAL movie is converted to an NTSC tape, 5 extra frames must be added per second or the action might seem jerky. The opposite is true for an NTSC movie converted to PAL. Five frames must be removed per second or the action may seem unnaturally slow.

Another difference between NTSC and PAL formats is resolution quality. PAL may have fewer frames per second, but it also has more lines than NTSC. PAL television broadcasts contain 625 lines of resolution, compared to NTSC's 525. More lines usually means more visual information, which equals better picture quality and resolution. Whenever an NTSC videotape is converted to PAL, black bars are often used to compensate for the smaller screen aspect, much like letterboxing for widescreen movies.

When the NTSC format was first adopted in 1941, there was little discussion of color transmissions. When the technology for color television arrived, engineers had to create a broadcast method which would still allow owners of monochrome television sets to receive a picture. Color signals on the NTSC format are still not considered ideal by electronics experts. The PAL system, on the other hand, was created after the advent of color broadcasting, so color signals are much truer to the original image.

For most purposes, the difference between NTSC and PAL signals are negligible. A European television set won't work in the United States and an NTSC formatted DVD won't play on a PAL player. But many people own home movies which cannot be viewed on a competing format. For this reason, there are a number of companies which offer conversion kits from NTSC to PAL or PAL to NTSC. Some of these conversion methods can be time-consuming and variable in quality, but others provide an easy way to create a PAL video for a European relative or an NTSC DVD for a Canadian friend. Some electronic media outlets may also provide conversion services for a price.

Related wiseGEEK articles

Category

wiseGEEK features

Subscribe to wiseGEEK


16
Does this whole NTSC vs. PAL systems affect hard drive media players? I purchased a hard drive media player in Hong Kong (PAL system and uses 220 voltage for power) and brought it back to North America (NTSC system and uses 110 voltage for power). The image that came out on my HD LCD tv was black and white and somewhat staggered. I got the same result when using it on an older CRT tv set and another LCD tv.

Of course, when I was testing the player in Hong Kong, everything was crystal clear. Any idea if this has anything to do with PAL vs. NTSC?

- anon58925
15
I have a Panasonic camera which can be set to PAL or NTSC. However what I do not understand is that this setting is not when I record a film, but when I download it to computer (or DVD). After the film is already recorded. The same recording can be displayed in two standards?
- anon57744
14
In Australia, newer TVs are capable of handling PAL and NTSC signals (I have both HD LCD and analogue CRT sets that do PAL and NTSC), as are the majority of DVD players. Format (in)compatibility is no longer the massive issue it used to be. I switch between NTSC and PAL movies without even thinking about it, they "just work" with the gear setup the way I have it.

I have read that a greater percentage of DVD players in the US can't handle PAL DVDs, but I wonder if a lot of that is improper configuration of the DVD player.

As for the questions about game consoles, the video generation is usually done at a relatively late stage, and the main issue would be whether the TV can handle the video format that the game console outputs. Modern plasma and LCD TVs (being digital devices capable of multiple resolution settings) should be OK in this regard.

Newer CRT sets may or may not work with a foreign format. Older sets will have a problem with foreign formats.

Note that if the game console uses an RF modulator (as opposed to A/V connections), you will have additional problems due to different channel frequencies and different vision/sound carrier spacing.

This can cause problems even between countries that use the same video format (e.g. UK and Australia, where the video/sound spacing is 6.0 MHz in the UK, vs 5.5 MHz in Oz).

Hope this helps.

- anon55838
13
Read your DVD player manual; I had trouble playing a NTSC disc on my PAL machine until I found out that the operator's manual describes how to change the setup to play either!
- anon47333
12
My sister in Madrid bought an LCD TV and is planning to bring it home to the Philippines by December. I'm sure that because of the difference in color frequency between Europe and the Philippines, she won't be able to use it there. Is there any converter that can solve this matter, and where can i find it?
- sitetrekker
11
I am thinking of bringing the LCD TV sets I bought last year in Singapore to the Philippines. Will there be a problem viewing the channels in the Philippines given that Singapore uses PAL while Philippines uses NTSC? Will it be worth bringing them over?
- aortiz3
10
If I have a PS3 in PAL format will it work in a NTSC HDTV?
- anon29163
8
It isn't how modern the dvd player is, and it is not the quality in terms of cost. It is the compatibility of the player. You can spend as little as 30 dollars and it plays absolutely everything. Phillips is a good inexpensive machine and plays both pal and nstc also plays divx mpeg vob you name it.
- anon23357
7
I was considering a purchase of game, Shadow of the colossus" in NTSC format. My TV has PAL but my PS2 has both. Are these problems includes only transmission of TV or PS2 may also cause them (if it has PAL system only, for example?)
- anon22841
6
If i want to get a NTSC Nintendo wii system, but i will like to use it on a pal hdtv, is this going to be a problem? Will it work or will i have compatibility issues?

It won't/shouldn't be a problem, although the picture won't be the best since the Wii doesn't output HD, but your HDTV should accept both signals theoretically. Its mainly the old analog TVs that will cause problems and then it usually only results in the TV vertical hold getting messed up and the game showing in black and white.

- anon21561
5
"If i want to get a NTSC Nintendo wii system, but i will like to use it on a pal hdtv, is this going to be a problem?"

Of course it won't work. Did you not read the article? PAL and NTSC are behind different electrical systems.

For DVDs (PS2 games are DVD) it depends if they are region coded or not. This comes down to the individual DVD (be it game or movie).

- anon16452
4
If i want to get a NTSC Nintendo wii system, but i will like to use it on a pal hdtv, is this going to be a problem? Will it work or will i have compatibility issues?
- anon15287
3
Perhaps it can go a bit further. I recently purchased a playstation 2 highschool musical game for a girlfriend's child in Australia. I didn't know of the different formats (pal vs ntsc). Is there some way to convert the game from ntsc to pal? --radx133
- anon14229
2
Wait, NTSC and PAL apply to VHS *and* DVD? I thought it was only VHS. I recently brought a US DVD to Europe and it worked fine in a European DVD player. I wonder if more modern DVD players actually accommodate both systems? Is that possible? Would the people that determine these things be so kind?!
- habura

FREE: Subscribe to wiseGEEK

 
    learn more

our strict privacy policy ensures that your email address will be safe



Written by Michael Pollick
Last Modified: 05 January 2010

copyright © 2003 - 2010
conjecture corporation