What Is the Difference Between a Republic and a Democracy?

language humanities

By definition, a republic is a political unit governed by a charter, while a democracy is a government whose prevailing force is always that of the majority. Perhaps one of the difficulties in defining these two words — democracy and republic — stems from the fact that many people consider them to be synonyms, which they aren’t. They are no more alike than an apple and a banana, and yet they are often used interchangeably.

The difference between a republic and a democracy lies in the ultimate source of official power. In the case of a republic, it lies with a charter; in a democracy, power lies with the rule of the majority. Yet they are often lumped together. Consider the words to the United States' Pledge of Allegiance, which adds to some of the confusion by proudly touting: "And to the republic for which its stands, one nation under God, indivisible ..."

Adding to the confusion is the fact that there are different types of democracies. A direct democracy is one which is ruled entirely and directly by the people; to decide on an issue, the question is put to the vote of the population and the majority of those votes determine the outcome. In a representative democracy, citizens elect people to represent their interests in the government, and these representatives determine how issues are decided.

In seeking clarification between a democracy and a republic, look no further than the names of American political parties and how they loosely define their boundaries. If nothing else, the names "republican" and "democrat" may be considered to characterize a Republican’s looser view of government and a Democrat’s centralized one. In a republic, people may vote for their representatives, but the state’s responsibilities are limited because they are clearly bound by a charter. Freedom is realized by the willingness of the people to live by the dictates of the charter. The republic’s charter protects the individual’s rights.

The detailed organization of the government of a republic can vary widely. In most cases, the head of state, as it is in France, for example, is referred to as the president. In republics, the head of state is always appointed as the result of either a direct or indirect election. In the case of some republics, such as Switzerland and San Marino, the head of state is actually a committee of several persons in aggregate. Republics can be led by a head of state who retains many characteristics of a monarch, and in some instances the president may rule for the duration of his life. Such an example would be the Syrian Arab Republic.

Republics and democracies represent two forms of representative government out of many found in the world today. The rights of the individual are always protected, no matter how they are represented.

Related wiseGEEK articles

Category

wiseGEEK features

Subscribe to wiseGEEK


17
anon12484, With all due respect, you are absolutely wrong when you said: "And the term Republican dates back to Abraham Lincoln and those who were committed to preserving the republic, rather than allowing it to dissolve." The term 'republic' goes back hundreds of years before Lincoln was born. But more important, Lincoln was committed to preserving the 'Union' so as to not let it dissolve. Anon43074 (8) was correct in his/her description. However, the quote they gave was a little off.

The correct quote, by Benjamin Franklin is: "A democracy is two wolves and a small lamb voting on what to have for dinner. Freedom under a constitutional republic is a well armed lamb contesting the vote".

- anon62339
16
shakabob wrote, in part, "Scary thought if the Power of the People were not ruled by the Constitution..." No, shakabob, the power of the government is ruled, or at least is supposed to be, by the Constitution. The power of the people is absolute; they are the real "sovereigns"(source of power, individually and collectively) from whom government derives it's just power. So it's not the government being sovereign as they constantly claim to be.

In effect, that claim by government suggests that government is superior to the people, which they are not supposed to be, but, of course, we have permitted them to become.

- anon62250
15
The United States is a republic. A republic is a government run by written law such as our Constitution.

The United States is not a democracy, and our Congress and Senate are bound to follow the constitution of the United States.

Most news media, school teachers, and even government officials do not know this. In 1776 Ben Franklin said we gave you a Republic. Thanks for reading. --Phil

- anon61171
14
anon43074 I agree with what you are saying.
- dontgivein
13
Is there any nation today which can call itself democratic but not a republic or vice versa? I guess not. Truth is, Republic alone without democracy will turn out to be a dictatorship or a monarchy, and a democracy without a republic will become anarchy.
- anon55875
10
America is the best damn nation on this earth.
- anon48094
9
What would the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC)be classified as?
- anon45474
8
In a Republic, such as the United States, the people do not vote on specific issues. We elect representatives to prepresent our views and they, limited by the rules of the Constitution (insert laugh track here) vote on the issues. My favorite quote is, "In a Democracy, two wolves and a sheep vote on what's for dinner. In a Constituional Republic, the wolves cannot vote on dinner and the sheep are well armed."
- anon43074
7
The article states, "In a democracy, to decide on an issue, the question is put to the vote of the population and the majority of those votes determine the outcome." How are issues decided in a republic?
- anon42119
6
It is true. The United States is a republic with democratic traditions; one cannot argue against that as it is apparent in many aspects of America's way of dealing with central issues. Now, to the United States' luck...this practice and/or social-political tradition has protected their land from internal coup d'etats...
- anon36113
5
Scary thought if the Power of the People were not ruled by the Constitution and the power of Ethical Law. I believe that only true Freedom is a Republic formed for the people and by the people with Laws that bind us together and a justice system that is blind.

Conservative Moderate

- shakabob
4
An oxymoron that I found is that I have seen an area on the map labeled as a "Democratic Republic".
- anon26767
3
Democracy is simply one-person, one-vote. A republic is a government comprised of democratically-elected representatives. And the term Republican dates back to Abraham Lincoln and those who were committed to preserving the republic, rather than allowing it to dissolve.
- anon12484
1
The World CIA Factbook cites the United States as a "Constitution-based federal republic with a strong democratic tradition." But it doesn't say that the United States is a democracy or even a democratic republic.
- rjohnson

FREE: Subscribe to wiseGEEK

 
    learn more

our strict privacy policy ensures that your email address will be safe



Written by M. Dee Dubroff
Last Modified: 26 January 2010

copyright © 2003 - 2010
conjecture corporation