Category: 

What is the Difference between a Comet and an Asteroid?

A comet's tails is generated by solar heating and the vaporizing of matter on the comet's surface.
Comets have icy surface, whereas an asteroid is mostly made of rock.
Comets have tails, but asteroids don't.
Article Details
  • Written By: Michael Anissimov
  • Edited By: Bronwyn Harris
  • Last Modified Date: 18 November 2014
  • Copyright Protected:
    2003-2014
    Conjecture Corporation
  • Print this Article
Free Widgets for your Site/Blog
Mandarin Chinese is most commonly spoken language in the world.  more...

November 24 ,  1971 :  A man hijacked a plane, parachuted out with $200,000 US Dollars (USD) and was never seen again.  more...

There are several important differences between comets and asteroids, though the distinction between the two is not absolute. The primary difference is that comets have a tail, whereas asteroids do not. Also important is that comets tend to have extremely elongated orbits, sometimes traveling as far as 50,000 AU (astronomical units, or Earth-Sun distances) or farther away from the Sun, though short-period comets only travel as far as the outer planets before returning to the inner solar system. Asteroids tend to have more circular orbits, and coalesce in belts, like the asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter or the Kuiper belt beyond the orbit of Neptune.

The tail and coma (atmosphere) of comets is generated by solar heating which vaporizes volatiles (substances with a low boiling point) on a comet's surface, especially ice, and causes it to be ejected all around the comet. Then, the solar wind carries away the vaporized materials, forming the tail. Though one may imagine that the tail extends behind the comet in the direction of its travel, space is a vacuum so there is no wind resistance to cause this to happen. Instead, the tail always points away from the Sun, changing its orientation as the comet orbits the Sun and is swung back into the outer solar system.

Ad

Many more asteroids are known than comets. As of 2008, only about 3,572 comets are known, while many millions of asteroids are known to exist. Most comets are believed to originate at locations very distant from the Sun, particularly the Oort cloud, a hypothesized belt of orbiting material located approximately 50,000 AU from the Sun. So, comets consist of those very few objects from the far outer solar system that have orbits that bring them close to the Sun. The very reason that ice exists on them in such large quantities is that they spend most of their time very far from the Sun, where ice is common and the Sun's rays are not intense enough to burn it off.

Conversely, most of the asteroids in the asteroid belt are located within the "snow line" of the solar system, meaning that their surfaces are dry as a bone -- all the ice has long been evaporated away. Most everything within this snow line is dry, with Earth (and ancient Mars) being a major exception. Because Earth is located within the snow line, it is believed that much of its initial water may have been deposited via comet impacts. Further water was produced by chemoautrophic bacteria, which can synthesize water out of hydrogen sulfide and atmospheric carbon dioxide.

Ad

More from Wisegeek

You might also Like

Discuss this Article

discographer
Post 3

@anamur-- I think comets' tails do become smaller and smaller and become nonexistent as they get farthest away from the sun.

I didn't read this anywhere but my teacher showed us pictures of Halley's comet when it was first seen. Astronomers took pictures of the comet for 14 months and the pictures showed the tail getting bigger and stronger as it neared the sun. The tail got smaller and smaller as it went farther away from the sun. In the last picture, the tail was like a small white dot.

So I guess the tails reform afresh every time their orbit nears the sun. And when they're in the "snow line," they pretty much die out as you said.

I think comets are the most fun to learn about. It's so cool that they're tail always points away from the sun. And it looks kind of curved too, it's not like a straight line.

burcidi
Post 2

@anamur-- About the size of comets and asteroids, they both vary a lot. But it's safe to say that asteroids are usually smaller. Comets can be as big as 20 kilometers long, and asteroids can be as long as 15 kilometers. Smallest comets and asteroids are pretty much the same size (less than a kilometer).

Comets and asteroid orbits are very different however. Comet orbits range anywhere from 5 years to over 200 earth years. Asteroid orbits are way smaller and are between 3 and 6 years. That's why comets are not as visible as asteroids.

Also asteroids are much more likely to go out of orbit. And there is a much higher chance of an asteroid hitting earth than a comet (thankfully!)

I hope this helps!

serenesurface
Post 1

I have homework on this subject and this article has been really helpful. But I'm still kind of confused about comets and asteroids.

First of all, comets are much larger than asteroids, right? If we were to compare, how much larger are they?

The other thing I don't understand is about comets' tails. I know the comets's tails form when they get close to the sun. But when they move away and into the snow line, don't the tails disappear? Do they maintain their tails even when they're far away?

Please help me if you know the answers!

Post your comments

Post Anonymously

Login

username
password
forgot password?

Register

username
password
confirm
email