The 18th Amendment to the US Constitution was ratified in 1919, and became one of the shorter lived and deeply controversial amendments of the constitution. Under the 18th Amendment, production, transportation and sale of alcohol was banned. The Amendment was passed with the Volstead Act, which helped to define those beverages considered alcoholic. The Volstead Act defined “intoxicating liquor” as containing .5% of alcohol or more.
Taken together, the 18th Amendment and the Volstead Act ushered in the Prohibition Era in the United States, which significantly increased illegal activity and the rise of the crime lords like Al Capone, who made much of his money through illegal manufacture, sales and transportation of alcohol. The 18th Amendment didn’t succeed in creating a countrywide temperance movement. It can be said that the pervasiveness of large and small operations to provide people with access to alcohol helped make these beverages still widely available. Only now they were illegal.
Part of the impetus in the various Temperance Movement groups that helped pressure Congress to pass the 18th Amendment was religious in nature. There were other reasons why women especially supported banning access to alcohol. As with today, domestic violence against women tended to be more significant in homes where alcohol was used to excess. However, there were strong opponents to the temperance movement who were strongly religious too, and the split between support and opposition to the bill cannot be viewed as a total separation between the religious and nonreligious.
Though the 18th Amendment might have ended the drinking careers of some, its passage created more social problems. First, alcohol was still widely available, so it didn’t necessarily mean that people had stopped drinking, and those who were alcoholics, very likely continued drinking regularly. The rise in organized crime was most significant and created increased violence, especially in urban areas. Not all people were eager to enforce the laws either, since many did not support the 18th Amendment.
Continued pressure to repeal the 18th Amendment was applied to US leaders, and ultimately, the Amendment was repealed by the 21st Amendment ratified in 1933. The 21st Amendment also made the provisions of the Volstead Act unconstitutional and therefore struck at the heart of the temperance movement and the goal of prohibition. The issues created by organized crime were partly solved by allowing sale, manufacture and transportation of alcohol again, though organized crime in various forms still continued to proliferate.
|
SilentBlue
Post 3 |
@ShadowGenius
I think that the question is moral as well as legal. If coffee were considered to be a mind-altering drug, perhaps we would have coffee street gangs. Although marijuana is a milder form of illegal drugs, it is nevertheless dangerous and can do great damage to productivity and mental capacity. Alcohol only does as much damage when consumed to excess. So perhaps drunkenness should be illegal. |
|
ShadowGenius
Post 2 |
Perhaps the same issue faced by proponents of the 18th Amendment can be compared to the issue faced by people against the legalization of marijuana today. The drug industry is the strongest pillar of underground crime and violence. If these drugs were legalized, wouldn't that eliminate a lot of gangs? |
|
Tufenkian925
Post 1 |
People made a lot of money brewing alcohol secretly and delivering their illegal "moonshine" to places like "speakeasy" bars. This regulation helped to foster the growth of many illegal organizations like the Mafia in America. With beer and wine being a central and intrinsic part of many cultures, the 18th Amendment also was perceived as discriminatory. To this day, the cultural meme of the "drunken Irishman" has continued in the American conscious. Italians were also seen as shady double-dealing and violent people. |