What is Entrapment?

world

Criminal defense lawyers have several legal strategies at their disposal, including a claim of police or governmental entrapment. Legally speaking, entrapment occurs whenever a police officer or other government agent deceives an innocent person into committing a crime he or she had no prior intention of committing. If a court determines that the charges against the defendant are based on entrapment, he or she cannot be convicted of the crime. The laws against police or governmental entrapment are intended to prevent law enforcement agencies from coercing a citizen into committing a crime, then arresting him or her for the act.

Entrapment charges often stem from vice crimes involving drugs, gambling or prostitution. Law enforcement agencies have the legal right to present their officers as drug dealers, prostitutes, gambling bookmakers or other professional criminals. Contrary to popular belief, these undercover agents do not have to reveal their true identities or legal affiliation when asked. It is not considered police entrapment if an undercover officer presents a supply of drugs to a potential buyer, for example. The buyer of those drugs commits a crime once the deal has been made, not during the initial contact with the undercover officer.

Law enforcement officers must be aware of their limitations during a sting operation to avoid later accusations of entrapment. An undercover officer working as a prostitute, for example, cannot initiate a conversation leading to the customer's solicitation offer. A defendant arrested for solicitation of a prostitute could claim that the undercover officer was flirtatious or made physical contact before identifying herself as a prostitute. An argument could be made that the solicitation was based on the officer's behavior, not on the defendant's intention to commit a crime.

Claims of entrapment can be notoriously difficult to prove. Some successful claims against law enforcement agencies have centered around the idea of a 'virtue test'. Police cannot select random citizens to participate in organized sting operations in hopes of generating an arrest. There must be some compelling evidence that a specific individual has a propensity for committing such a crime.

Another reason entrapment is difficult to prove in court is the criminal history of the defendant. If the prosecution can demonstrate a previous history of similar crimes, then it becomes extremely difficult to prove entrapment. Providing an opportunity to commit a crime is not considered entrapment.

This is why police stings involving Internet sex crimes have been successful. Defendants may claim that adult police officers posing as underage chatroom participants constitutes entrapment, for instance. The reality is that the undercover agent only provided an opportunity for the suspect to initiate illegal conversations.

There have been a number of successful entrapment defenses mounted throughout the years, mostly involving high-level government stings. The operation itself may become criminal in nature, or an overzealous agent may use coercive techniques to pressure someone into committing a crime. Many cases involving possible entrapment become very high-profile, such as the drug case against former automaker John DeLorean during the 1980s or the Abscam case involving a number of federal lawmakers accused of accepting bribes from foreign investors.

Related wiseGEEK articles

Category

wiseGEEK features

Subscribe to wiseGEEK


40
I know this to be true, but to prove it would be extremely difficult.

Proving this may start with those who have experienced this. With certain questions, such as. Is it possible that before your troubles began, had you do anything that would show leadership ability? Had you made statements over the telephone that were of a negative nature about the government? Had you attended college? Were you fired from your last job without any reason?

Do you remember anyone bumping you from behind, and excusing himself for bumping you?

I would believe that you are familiar with Operation Chaos, started in 1967.

A version of this has never stopped. In this operation, African Americans, and others are covertly microchipped, or unwittingly microchipped. By this I mean an undercover operative walks up behind the individual and bumps him in the buttocks, actually jabs a needle into the person's butt, and inserts a extremely small microchip --an RFID.

This allows remote identification of the microchipped individual, tracking and even altering of the reality that this person experiences.

Street theater is constantly performed as the person goes about his daily affairs.

In this manner the individual can be steered into an entrapment scheme.  

I would have to estimate that a very large percentage of drug offenders who are incarcerated were covertly microchipped before they began their drug offenses.

- anon52796
39
Is it legal for a cop to tell you to get in your vehicle and leave town, knowing I was drinking because it was a bar scene fight is the reason he told me to leave town. Then when I drove off, he pulled me over down the road and arrested me for DUI.
- anon51707
38
is it legal for an undercover to come to your house for a massage and strip naked, touch you and you touch him, and bust you for prostitution, even if sex were never discussed?
- anon51648
37
i see everyone here must watch cop shows. a lot of entrapment on there. a lot of police brutality. always said you can't take a person in uniform and put them on tv and expect them to act normally. every one of these shows need to be taken off the air.
- anon50892
36
Entrapment sucks. Talk about our freedom being taken. If a pig poses as a drug dealer and you go up to him to buy something, then you both should be arrested. Why is it illegal for me to want to buy drugs, but legal for them to sell them? This country just gets more screwed up by the day. A few more years until I retire and I'm gone.
- anon49003
35
Wow, after reading a lot of these posts, I have come to realize there is some pretty messed up stuff going on -- in the public and in the police departments! I'm not sure who is the problem here, the people or the government? Seems like both are at fault with this mess. People need to get their heads on straight. Try praying to God a little and don't lie so much.
- anon46460
34
Is it entrapment when an alleged "victim" of a crime calls one the defendant's family members stating they feel bad about what happened and wants to get a statement notarized that says she was under the influence and was not raped as she had told police. Then asks for money to get the statement notarized because she didn't have the money? The charges are tampering with a witness and bribery.
- anon42308
33
I was arrested in a sting op. two undercover officers went to my shop and offered me stolen plasma TV's. I said no the first and second time, but they insisted too much. they even dropped the price of those televisions to $100 each. I couldn't resist, and as soon as I gave them the money, eight patrols stopped by and arrested me for theft, buying stolen merchandise. My question is that these televisions were not stolen, as a matter of fact. A store gave them to the police for the sting. do they have to prove that in fact I was buying "stolen" televisions?
- anon39672
32
is it entrapment if a friend calls and asks someone to get pot for friends of theirs and the friends happen to be under cover?
- anon39282
31
If a bookmaker is getting under 16s to go in to bookmakers and place bets then suspending staff that have accepted the bet believing the customer is over 18, would that be considered entrapment?
- anon38546
30
Is it entrapment if a corrections officer who also works as a pizza delivery person comes on your property to deliver pizza and sees something illegal, and then discloses the information to the law enforcement agents, who then proceed with a bust of the property?
- anon35796
29
I am doing a homework assignment for a business law class. My question is regarding pedophilia and entrapment. If police set up a sting operation to investigate if the suspect is staying innocent, after being released from prison with no complaints or incidents following his release, is this entrapment?

Police officers in this case along with the FBI set up a mailer that advertised child pornography, which was set to be a fictitious circular. After the 17th issue to his home address, he subscribed, sent in his check and was arrested for solicitation of pornographic materials. His lawyer argued entrapment. Is this a legal argument in this case?

- anon27561
28
Is it entrapment when the traffic cops are directing mass crowds out of a parking lot regardless of the red lights and then less than 100 yards away pull over and ticket 10 more cars for turning right on red at the next intersection? Just doesn't seem right. Oh and yeah, we were coming out of church on sunday morning.
- anon25390
27
tell me what is the chance of this case being prosecuted to make this as short as possible my son was getting text messages one night 16 to be exact from this guy he knew from his pass he kept ignoring them until him and 2 of his friends drove to the next town to meet up with guy the guy wanted to buy pot he gave my son 800 dollars and the three of them drove off the police task force pounced on them right away, hence no drugs were found not even a seed but my son and his two friends were charged with 2 counts of theft and conspiring to commit theft, what is their defense besides stupidity entrapment, reward for not selling drugs, if this was not a police sting operation there wouldnt have been a case, the person trying to buy drugs isnt going to police to report the guy took my money and didnt give me drugs
- onekarw
26
In order to use entrapment as a legal excuse, law enforcement must have coerced you into committing a criminal act. Acts such as buying alcohol for a minor or speeding are strict liability offenses, meaning that there is no excuse for committing the offense. In these instances, the entrapment excuse for committing a criminal act may not be used.
- anon23022
25
is it entrapment if a undercover cop get you to sell them drugs more then once without arresting you the first time you did it? and can you be charged with trafficking cc with out being caught with it or money used by the undercover cop?

and i was driving my sister car can i be pulled over for a warrant if the car is not registered under my name?

- space
23
A co-worker working as a mutual clerk at a major thoroughbred track got too much money for the tickets that were bought. We were busy and he didnt realize this until the customer (sent out to test the clerks from the office) reported that fact to the mutual manager. Co-worker got suspended even though NJ racing commission states that when a customer leaves the window its assumes that all tickets and money are correct. Is this entrapment or not?
- anon16124
22
Coming from Europe, I wonder, why US courts ignore human rights issues in entrapment cases. For, international courts did set very high standards about the admissibility of intrusive police methods. For instance, in February 2008 the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights ruled in the case of Ramanauskas v. Lituvia, that the government must prove the absence of entrapment. (The case involved a bribery, that was finally accepted, after it was declined twice.)

Moreover, there is the question of proportionality: Police uses an intrusive method to explore the sexual life of consenting adults, while the original purpose of this method was the fight of organized mafia crime, not petty crimes.

- anon15731
21
What can be said in a discussion with a supposed prostitute to avoid being arrested for solicitation if she turns out to be a cop? How can you know you are dealing with a police officer and not a hooker?
- chuck159
19
I was coerced and entrapped at an adult bookstore after a undercover officer asked me "Let me see it, " several times. I was coerced into this..can I be let go without charge? --anonymous.
- anon14865
18
If a person mistakenly pulls over in a red bus zone and then tries to re-enter traffic because they realize they are in a redzone... then a police officer cuts the person off when the person is trying to pull out then has another police officer pull up behind the car so the car can not leave.. then gives a ticket for parking in a redzone, even though the car was never off, no one ever left the car, the car was just stopped a moment then attempting to re-enter traffic and get out of redzone.. would that be considered entrapment? The driver got a $250 ticket for parking in a red / bus zone but the only time they were actually parked with car off is when the police forced them to park so they could ticket the person.
- anon14284
17
if police officer forces keys in a person, who they know is drunk and forces them to drive by verbally, threatening the person to leave his home and the person is pulled over by another law enforcement and arrested a few minutes later by officers of the same county, and knowingly knows the person is drunk. is that consider to be entrapment? i need too know?
- anon13391
16
Is it legal for a Highway Patrol officer to be parked in the emergency lane of the freeway completely shut down, not showing any visible light at approx. 1 in the morning? Is it then legal for him to stop someone and give them a ticket? Also, is it legal for him to make you roll up your windows when he has already pulled you over?
- anon13219
15
What constitutes an "illegal conversation"?
- anon12239
14
I need some advice! Tonight I got set up in a sting operation. I was going to 711 to buy some feminine products and a kid walks up to me and asks if I could buy him a 6 pack. It was dark out so I couldn't really see his face so I asked if he was the cops. He laughed and said "no, I just don't have my ID and the lady wont sell to me. I'm 20 years old." I said I understood and bought the poor soul some beer. I walked out asked the guy to go around the corner, he said no, grabbed the beer, gave me ten bucks and took off. Five cops rolled on me, put me in cuffs and arrested me. Just to give you some background I'm five foot nothin, blonde, and petite. Why do five cops think it's necessary to put me in cuffs and treat me like [that]? I so don't need this right now; trying to get into nursing school in the fall and applying for jobs this summer.
- stinger
13
For the last post, no that is not a case of entrapment. Your friend still purchased cocaine, with the intent to sell it later that night. The best thing to do in that situation would have been to say "no, im not getting you an illegal substance"
- anon9236
12
Would this be entrapment: This guy I know was asked to get some cocaine for someone, when he got it he was recorded selling it to the guy under direction of the Drug strike force. This guy does not sell cocaine and does not have any prior of this charge he only got it for the guy because they had known each other for a while and where friends.
- anon8612
11
justme - Profiling is an Art of Policing and is not illegal in most states. Besides, illegal profiling; that of prioritizing past offenses to encounter a suspect multiple times, is done daily by good police departments. The difference is, you won't find public record of it, so you can't prove it.

Anonymous (prostitution) - You would be breaking the law if you sexually engage with one.

Anonymous (bar) - Entrapment? Seriously...Probable Cause allows the officer to pull you over if he sees something conspicuous (stumbling, etc.). If he put a gun to your head outside the bar and forced you to drive drunk, that could be entrapment.

DJCamper - Doubtful. They are still only providing you with the opportunity.

I'm NOT a police officer, nor am I an attorney. However, I have had many dealings with the law through my father, a long-term officer, and have helped the PD here locally with certain operations. Therefore, this is NOT legal advice.

- anon6986
10
if a police officer feels you filed a false police report, then continues to go to the person's residence, and says to another person or that person, "the prosecutor sent me to ask more questions," and says he lied, he used entrampment, on that person he feels committed a crime, is that considered legal, and how so?
- anon5710
9
I was arrested in a sting operation.

I told the undercover officer I was HIV positive. He told me if I was not interested in him I could be with his partner but not to tell him that I'm positive.

Could this be considered entrapment?

- DJCamper
7
Can a cop park outside of a bar and wait to pull over the first person to walk out? Is that considered entrapment?
- anon4518
6
what is the difference between being accused of entrapment and being the one entrapped? and since it is a defense, then there has to be a crime done by the defendant before he/she can claim entrapment, right?
- anon3339
5
If your are approached by a man that is trying to sell you drugs and you clearly ask him if he is law enforcement can he say no and it will be ok. I always thought that they could try to avoid the question but they couldn't just out right deny being an officer.
- rap7hundred
4
What can be said in a discussion with a known prostitute to avoid being arrested for solicitation?

How can you know you are dealing with a police officer and not a hooker?

- anon2376
2
Wouldn't that be considered profiling?
- anon2189
1
Is it leagal for a police officer to pull you over because he knows your car or who you are because of a past encounter? example, He pulled you over once and you did not have a driver lic. And now every time he sees your car he pulls it over.

- justme

FREE: Subscribe to wiseGEEK

 
    learn more

our strict privacy policy ensures that your email address will be safe



Written by Michael Pollick
Last Modified: 17 November 2009

copyright © 2003 - 2009
conjecture corporation