Category: 

What Is a Post Hoc Fallacy?

A child who falls asleep after bouts of insomnia from worrying may come to believe in the power of the worry doll.
Article Details
  • Written By: Alan Rankin
  • Edited By: Melissa Wiley
  • Last Modified Date: 10 December 2014
  • Copyright Protected:
    2003-2014
    Conjecture Corporation
  • Print this Article
Free Widgets for your Site/Blog
On average, people spend a year of their lives looking for items they've misplaced.  more...

December 18 ,  1620 :  The Mayflower landed in Plymouth.  more...

A post hoc fallacy is a logical fallacy, a statement that appears correct on its surface but does not hold up on deeper examination. “Post hoc” is short for post hoc, ergo proper hoc, a Latin phrase meaning “after this, therefore because of this.” It presumes that because one event occurs after another, the first event must have caused the second event. This is the foundation for many superstitions and spurious beliefs from prehistory to the present. In reality, there may be no cause-and-effect relationship between the two events.

Logic is the science of distinguishing factual information from supposition and unfounded belief. Logical fallacies are common misconceptions that are nonetheless regarded as true by large groups of people. These generally fall into certain widely recognized categories. The study of logic is thousands of years old; consequently, many logical fallacies are named in Latin, which was once the language of scientific and legal discourse.

Ad

The post hoc fallacy is a very common kind of misconception. Most people discover the law of cause and effect at a very young age. Since a cause always precedes its effect, this can lead to the mistaken notion that a given event caused a following event, when the relationship between the two events may be different or entirely nonexistent. A classic illustration is known as the rooster syndrome; roosters commonly crow at dawn, preceding the sunrise. A primitive society or a child might therefore believe the rooster’s crow causes the sun to rise.

Many rituals, traditions, and beliefs have been created as a result of the post hoc fallacy. Primitive societies, witnessing a solar eclipse, often performed elaborate rituals to “bring the sun back.” When the sun did return, they concluded their rituals were successful and decided to practice them at every eclipse. Faith healers and other magical remedies have often benefited from this fallacy when their work seemed to produce beneficial results in ill or injured subjects. In reality, the recovery was probably due to the subject’s immune system and natural healing capacity.

The post hoc fallacy, however, is not limited to primitive cultures. Many modern-day superstitions result from this kind of misconception. Amateur and professional athletes may decide that an item or article of clothing is a lucky charm if they wore it during a particularly successful game. In political discourse, pundits and elected officials often indulge in post hoc fallacies when they quote anecdotal evidence to promote or discredit a particular policy. Anything that does not support this argument, including actual scientific evidence, is accidentally or deliberately ignored.

Ad

More from Wisegeek

You might also Like

Discuss this Article

Jolecter
Post 2
They can be funny when coming from children, but not necessarily so when coming from adults. For example, I think that one type of this might be the slippery slope fallacy. This is one I have seen a number of times from politicians. An exaggerated version of this might be saying something like “If we increase the speed limit on the highway to 75, we will have deaths from car accidents every 30 minutes.”
Ledgenderous
Post 1

The article mentions that we learn cause and effect at an early age. I think that this might be why I often hear examples of the post hoc fallacy when talking to my friends’ children. These can often be quite humorous!

Post your comments

Post Anonymously

Login

username
password
forgot password?

Register

username
password
confirm
email