Category: 

What is a Legal Fiction?

Article Details
  • Written By: Mary McMahon
  • Edited By: Kristen Osborne
  • Last Modified Date: 09 November 2016
  • Copyright Protected:
    2003-2016
    Conjecture Corporation
  • Print this Article
Free Widgets for your Site/Blog
Contrary to popular belief, monkeys do not eat bananas in the wild because the banana is a cultivated fruit.  more...

December 6 ,  1877 :  Edison demonstrated the first sound recording.  more...

A legal fiction is a presumption of facts that is intended to facilitate an equitable resolution to a legal situation. Legal fictions are assumed for convenience or when a case could not be resolved without adopting such a fiction. They cannot be used to controvert the law or impede justice.

When a court adopts a legal fiction, it either makes an assumption based on available information in a case or it presumes a fact in order to facilitate the hearing of the case. Sometimes the assertion is actually not true, but it is assumed to be so for the purposes of the court. People have an opportunity to challenge the assumption if they believe that it would result in a miscarriage of justice.

There are a number of situations in which creating a legal fiction may be necessary to apply the law or to resolve a case. It is not uncommon to use a legal fiction to avoid cumbersome and circuitous handling of a case in court. If a fact can be presumed to be true for the purposes of the court, it can move the case along more efficiently to a swift and appropriate resolution.

Ad

One classic example is corporate personhood. Prior to the widespread development of corporations, if people had legal grievances with companies, they could sue the owners or partners directly. Once companies started incorporating, there was no person to sue, so the legal fiction of corporate personhood was created to provide plaintiffs with someone to bring suit against.

Another situation comes up in adoptions. When adoption paperwork is processed, the natural parents of the child become, for legal purposes, strangers, while the adoptive parents become the child's parents. This legal fiction does not erase the genetic connection between child and biological parents. It does facilitate the adoption process, providing the adoptive parents with rights and responsibilities related to the child.

The handling of wills and estates can also involve legal fictions. One situation which can cause problems with handling an estate is simultaneous death, in which couples die together in accidents or catastrophes. If the contents of the wills conflict with each other, a determination must be made to decide which one died first and which will takes precedence. Since it is not possible to literally find out which person died first, the court creates a legal fiction so that the estates can be distributed appropriately.

Ad

You might also Like

Recommended

Discuss this Article

ceilingcat
Post 3

I think the idea of a legal fiction as far as handling a will is kind of interesting. I don't know how you would even make that decision if the couple died at the same time and you couldn't figure out who actually passed away first.

Maybe they would just do it by whoever has the most up to date will? Either way it sounds like that could be a big mess. A lot of people go crazy when estates are settled and I feel like they would go crazier if the court just had to randomly decide which will they were going to use.

KaBoom
Post 2

@Monika - A legal fiction does seem to make sense in the case of adoption. However, I feel like the idea of corporate personhood is patently ridiculous.

It seems like a good idea, because it allows someone to sue the corporation. However, I think it really allows corporate head honchos to get away with doing shady stuff. I bet they would all behave a bit better if they could be sued individually for wrongdoing.

When the whole company gets sued, everyone who works there could end up suffering. Even low level workers who have nothing to do with the decision making process. It just doesn't seem fair!

Monika
Post 1

A legal fiction kind of sounds like it would be a bad thing. There shouldn't be any "fictions" in a court of law! But I can see that it actually helps expedite certain legal processes.

I thought the adoption example was a pretty good one. In reality, the child's biological parents are her biological parents. But in order for an adoption to actually work, the court needs to use a legal fiction that the parents are strangers. Imagine if both the biological and the adoptive parents had parental rights over the child! It would be a mess!

Post your comments

Post Anonymously

Login

username
password
forgot password?

Register

username
password
confirm
email