Learn something new every day
More Info... by email
A commuter tax is a tax on income earned within a taxing jurisdiction by people who live elsewhere. These taxes are usually calculated at a rate lower than that charged to residents, but sometimes only marginally so, and are most often charged by cities on workers who commute from neighboring areas. In regions where some jurisdictions charge such a tax, neighboring jurisdictions, if they impose the same type of tax, often give their taxpayers a credit for commuter taxes paid.
In the United States, the mechanism for collecting commuter taxes is much the same as for other income taxes, with employers withholding the proper amount due and the taxpayers reconciling amounts earned and paid when they file their annual income tax returns. This can be a complex process for taxpayers who travel often, because income earned outside the taxing jurisdiction, such as when on a business trip, is excluded from a commuter tax. Another potential complication for taxpayers is a two-tiered approach to taxing commuters, with out-of-state commuters charged at a higher rate than those from other locations in the same state.
In many metropolitan areas, the core cities provide more employment opportunities than the rest of the region. Commuters make frequent use of their taxpayer-funded or subsidized services, such as mass transportation, streets, and sidewalks, police and fire protection and, when necessary, public hospitals. Proponents of the tax say that commuters, who in some cities outnumber the residents, should pay their fair share toward all public services.
Opponents of taxing commuters point out that they already contribute a great deal to the local economy where they work, both in terms of their direct purchases and the sales taxes paid on them. In addition, thousands of private jobs in each metropolitan area exist just to serve the needs of commuters, jobs which themselves generate tax revenue. The cities also impose significant tax burdens on the companies that employ commuters, which may cover the cost of city services. If commuters were actually such a drain on local economies, insist the opponents, cities wouldn't try to attract new jobs.
An interesting feature of the commuter tax is that it often works both ways — that is, since there are some people who live in the city and work in the suburbs, those outlying areas establish their own commuter taxes. In many regions, this has led to reciprocal taxing agreements that provide for credit to taxpayers for commuter taxes paid. The effect of this is that commuters pay the commuter tax, and then receive a credit from their own taxing jurisdictions for the actual dollar amount of that tax. Under this system, commuters' overall tax liability is not increased unless their home county or city does not impose income tax at all.
@Soulfox -- on the other side, proponents of such taxes tend to point out that people leaving cities for the suburbs take away from the city's tax base. That means people who simply work in cities enjoy the infrastructure, police protection and other services offered in the city but aren't contributing a dime toward them. The commuter tax, they argue, helps cure that disparity and provides cities with the income they need to keep functioning as they should. If someone chooses to work in a city and expects certain services, why not make them pay their fair share?
People can live wherever they want, but the commuter tax shifts some of the burden from the people who live in cities
to those who don't but still want services. Why make people who live near the "jobs" that attract commuters pay for services for "outsiders?"
That's not saying that commuter taxes are fair or unfair. It's just good to see both sides of the issue.
Some have argued, further, that commuter taxes infringe on a person's right to travel. Effectively, they argued they are being discriminated against simply because they choose to live in the suburbs rather than closer to work and that is simply not the type of thing the government should do.
Still others claim a commuter tax isn't about additional revenue as much as it is about trying to keep people from moving out of urban areas to outlying communities.
One of our editors will review your suggestion and make changes if warranted. Note that depending on the number of suggestions we receive, this can take anywhere from a few hours to a few days. Thank you for helping to improve wiseGEEK!