Learn something new every day
More Info... by email
As with any food that is essentially pure fat, there are still health problems associated with margarine, especially if it is eaten in large quantities. One of the biggest potential problems is the increased risk of heart disease. Many kinds contain high levels of saturated fats and dangerous trans fats, which are known to lower the levels of beneficial high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol and increase levels of the harmful type known as low-density lipoprotein (LDL).
Once butter became associated with health risks such as heart disease due to its high levels of saturated fat and cholesterol, many people were looking for an alternative. Often individuals would switch to margarine, which often has no cholesterol and at least lower levels of saturated fat than butter and frequently fewer calories. The reason there is no cholesterol is because margarine is made from solidified vegetable fat instead of animal sources. As time passed, health professionals began to note health issues such as increased risk of developing heart disease for individuals who consumed margarine as well.
Researchers have found that the risk of heart disease associated with margarine is due to the presence of trans fatty acids, also known as trans fats. These substances are formed in the process of solidifying the vegetable oil and have been linked to several health issues. Solid sticks have much higher levels of trans fats than softer spreads. Trans fats have been shown to have an adverse effect on cholesterol levels, a major heart disease indicator, even though margarine does not actually contain cholesterol. The trans fats lower the levels of good HDL cholesterol and raise the amount of harmful LDL cholesterol found in the body.
Another contributing factor to the heart disease risk associated with margarine is the amount of saturated fat found in many brands. Even though there is less saturated fat than butter, high levels can be present in some margarine products. The amounts of these unhealthy substances can vary widely depending on the manufacturer. As a rule, it's a good idea for consumers to look for products with low levels of saturated fat and remember to use them in moderation.
Many manufacturers have removed as much trans fat as possible from their products, and many margarine types are also now made with unsaturated fats such as olive or canola oil. Products with reduced saturated fat and no trans fat are less harmful than others, but should still only be consumed in moderation. Consuming large amounts of any fatty food is likely to increase the chances of developing heart disease, but limiting consumption to small amounts of unsaturated fat reduces this risk.
@Phaedrus- I agree with you on the trans fat/saturated fat issue, but I still use margarine more often than butter. I think margarine works better than butter in some recipes, especially cookies and doughs. Butter may be a more natural kind of fat than margarine, but I think there really is a healthy margarine out there. I try to use the margarine spreads made with real olive oil when I can.
To me, the health risks with both butter and margarine should definitely be a consideration for a person's diet, but I personally won't switch to a margarine substitute until my doctor tells me I need to do it. My overall health is still pretty good, and I've been eating margarine for over 50 years. It's what my mom put on the table for everything.
For many years, I bought margarine instead of butter because of all the health warnings about butter. I always assumed there was such a thing as healthy margarine, so I'd often buy the margarine spreads that advertised themselves as heart-friendly or low fat or low sodium.
Now I have gone back to using real butter almost exclusively. The idea of eating that many trans fats scares me. Saturated fats, like the kind found in butter, aren't exactly great for my heart health, but at least the saturated fat molecules are too big to get absorbed by arteries, unlike trans fat molecules. They get stuck all the time and start building up until a dangerous clog forms. People need to do their own research and learn the truth about trans fats or partially hydrogenated oil.
One of our editors will review your suggestion and make changes if warranted. Note that depending on the number of suggestions we receive, this can take anywhere from a few hours to a few days. Thank you for helping to improve wiseGEEK!