Category: 

What are the Origins of the Phrase "Throw the Baby Out With the Bathwater"?

Article Details
  • Written By: Mary McMahon
  • Edited By: O. Wallace
  • Last Modified Date: 30 March 2014
  • Copyright Protected:
    2003-2014
    Conjecture Corporation
  • Print this Article
Free Widgets for your Site/Blog
A 2003 blackout affected 50 million people in North America and had an economic impact of about $10 billion USD.  more...

April 23 ,  :  William Shakespeare was born and died. (1564, 1616)  more...

The phrase “throw the baby out with the bathwater” appears to be German in origin, and it essentially means that the good should not be discarded along with the bad due to inattention or haste. Before one gets a mental image of flying babies and dirty bathwater, it should be added that this term was always used as a metaphor to suggest that people should not race to hasty decisions, not that parents would actually throw their baby out.

No one is quite sure when the Germans first started saying that one shouldn't throw the baby out with the bathwater, but by the 1600s, the term was common enough for it to be referenced by astronomer Johannes Kepler in a way which suggested that he assumed that his readers knew what he was talking about. From Germany, the slang term spread to France, and then into England. By 1853, Thomas Carlyle was mentioning the need to avoid tossing the baby out with the bathwater, and he also referenced the fact that the proverb was of German origin.

Ad

One might reasonably wonder how it is that people could even imagine that someone could throw the baby out with the bathwater by accident. The explanation for this term lies in the fact that Europeans bathed infrequently after the Middle Ages, for a variety of reasons; many people, for example, thought that bathing was unhealthy, and avoided it except on rare occasions. When people did bathe, they filled a large tub with water heated on the stove, and the whole family took turns using it, with the oldest going first.

By the time young children reached the bathtub, the water would be tepid, and rather dirty, thanks to the previous bathers. One can easily imagine an infant slipping into the water and becoming obscured by the muddy gloom, although since someone had to be present to bathe the infant, it is unlikely that the baby would have slipped entirely below the surface, or that someone would have dumped the baby out when emptying the tub, since most people keep track of the location of their babies. The image of tossing the cloudy contents of the bath without pulling the baby out first would have been compelling to Europeans living in this era, even if it never actually happened.

This slang term references the idea that hasty decisions can sometimes result in disastrous consequences. Sometimes, it is necessary to take a break to find the good and the bad in a situation before making a choice about what to do; in other words, take the baby out of the tub so that you don't toss him or her away.

Ad

Discuss this Article

anon133834
Post 3

I heard an entirely different origin for the phrase. In the middle ages, people bathed once or twice a year. And they did so according to the status in the house. So, the man went first, then the wife, and then the children in order. So, by the time the baby was bathed, the water was grimy and nasty. So, they had to be careful to not throw the baby out with the bathwater.

WalrusTusk
Post 2

@ChickenLover - I was grossed out as all get out when I read that too! It really does make you think if people were that forgetful or inattentive, but I think the deeper meaning of the phrase is what is important here. The phrase means to not act hasty or be impulsive to the point that it damages what you were trying to achieve in the first place. Know what I mean?

ChickenLover
Post 1

Interesting article and I've never heard the phrase, "throw out the baby with the bathwater," and must admit I had a mental image and was horrified. Once I read through where it was discussing bathing in medieval times I was literally screwing my face up in disgust! It is funny how things have changed so dramatically over time to the point that it would make us wonder where the heck it was we came from!

Post your comments

Post Anonymously

Login

username
password
forgot password?

Register

username
password
confirm
email