Category: 

What are the Main Concerns About the Ethics of Gene Therapy?

Article Details
  • Written By: J.M. Densing
  • Edited By: R. Halprin
  • Last Modified Date: 09 November 2016
  • Copyright Protected:
    2003-2016
    Conjecture Corporation
  • Print this Article
Free Widgets for your Site/Blog
Although they mainly functioned as downspouts, gargoyles were also intended to scare people into attending church.  more...

December 3 ,  1989 :  The Cold War officially ended.  more...

There are many issues and questions about the ethics of gene therapy surrounding the practice. Gene therapy involves making changes to a person's genetic profile, which is like a set of instructions or a blueprint for that unique individual. One of the ethical concerns involves whether it's morally right to make such changes, especially if they may also affect future generations. Other concerns about the ethics of gene therapy have to do with the application of the technique; many feel it's acceptable to use it to treat harmful disorders but not to enhance a person's fundamental traits. There are also concerns relating to accessibility of these expensive treatments and the risk of them becoming reserved for the wealthy.

Ad

One of the main concerns about the ethics of gene therapy has to do with the existence of the practice itself and whether it's morally acceptable. All types of gene therapy involve permanently altering the genetic profile of an individual; one type called germline gene therapy allows the changes to be passed on to offspring and future generations. Opponents of the practice express reservations about the risks of unknown long range side effects and developmental problems for future generations and believe that more study is necessary before taking these risks. Some also take issue with gene therapy on religious grounds because they view it as tampering with God's design. Supporters of gene therapy cite the enormous potential to save lives and eradicate genetic disorders and seem to feel the rewards are worth the risks.

Another serious concern about the ethics of gene therapy is that it has the potential to be misused. Many individuals agree that it can be beneficial for the treatment of life-altering harmful disorders. There are concerns, however, that this could lead to using it to eliminate any difference from society's ideal. Some people are concerned that gene therapy could be the beginning of genetic engineering to create the "perfect" human. Another concern is the potential abuse of gene therapy to enhance a person's performance, thereby altering abilities such as intelligence, speed, or coordination. Researchers and the American Medical Association agree that such uses of gene therapy would be a violation of ethics and shouldn't be permitted.

There are also issues about the cost of treatment related to the ethics of gene therapy. Given the experimental nature of gene therapy, it is very expensive, and usually not covered by medical insurance. The cost makes gene therapy treatments out of reach for most individuals since it is generally only affordable for the very rich. There is concern that gene therapy could become an exclusive treatment reserved for the wealthy elite, with others denied access. In keeping with the medical code of ethics, many in the medical community are committed to making it accessible to all regardless of socioeconomic status.

Ad

You might also Like

Recommended

Discuss this Article

ZipLine
Post 3

I'm not opposed to gene therapy but I don't support it either. I think it may be useful, but I also acknowledge all of the risks associated with it.

There is no doubt that if gene therapy becomes a regular treatment, people will certainly abuse it and use if for wrong ends. Those who can use it will use it to design themselves and their children. The true purpose and benefit of the therapy will be lost and I fear that. I also fear that with gene therapy, there will be people who practically live forever.

turquoise
Post 2

@ysmina-- I don't think that gene therapy is unethical from a religious standpoint. Think of it this way, if God did not want us to change a person's genes, he would not have allowed us to develop this medical technology in the first place. Think about all of the good that can come from this therapy. Think of all the people with genetic disorders who would be freed of their suffering.

ysmina
Post 1

I think that my biggest concern about gene therapy is a religious one. I do believe that each person has a divine plan just for them. It's determined by God and our genetic makeup is a part of this plan. It may seem fatalistic to some people, but it's true.

God gives people different genes because this is part of each individual's test. We don't choose to have brown eyes or blonde hair. And our physical characteristics have an impact on our life and how people view us and approach us. Playing with a person's genes is no different from trying to play God. And in my opinion, no one has the right to do that, it's completely wrong from a religious perspective.

Post your comments

Post Anonymously

Login

username
password
forgot password?

Register

username
password
confirm
email