What are the Differences Between the Sunni and Shia Sects of Islam?
The difference between Sunni and Shia sects of Islam do not exist to the dramatic degree many Western's assume. While there are slight variations in the way they view their religious leaders and attach meaning to the history of Muhammad's family, cultural and political differences hold the most divisive power. Both sects emphasize the Five Pillars of Islam, read the same Quran, and consider each other Muslims.
The split between these two significant sects of Islam can be traced back to the 600s, soon after Muhammed's death in 632. Muhammed's son-in-law, Ali, gained support as the inheritor of the duty to spread Islam. Thus, "Shia" is an abbreviation of "Shiat Ali," or the people of Ali. Not all Muslims believed in Ali's place as a leader. Yet this group respected Muhammed's relative as a holy man. He was not a Messiah, as there is only one Messiah. Rather, the Shi'ites regarded him as the first in a series of Imam, or the direct descendents of Muhammad who act as messengers of God. There were 12 Imams before the bloodline died out in the 800s. Each of these Imams now has subsects devoted to their worship within Shia Islam. Shi'ites comprise 10-15% of all Muslims as the second largest sect, but that number is higher in certain countries such as Iran.
The majority of Muslims are Sunni, the largest and more orthodox sect of Islam. Sunnis do not attach any special power to the Imam, but have a rather less structured hierarchy of religious leaders. Some have compared their system as similar in spirit to Protestantism, where ministers are important advisers and community leaders, but they are neither infallible nor chosen by God. These leaders, called Caliphs, teach Islam. They bring peace, dignity, and goodwill to their members and encourage following the laws and guidelines laid out in the Quran. Also, they do not rule the place of worship in the sense of excluding other kinds of Muslims. All mosques are nondenominational, and can receive prayers from any sect.
Some exaggerated differences between Sunnis and Shi'ites are their organization of community religious leaders and their method of prayer. It's true that Shi'ites focus more on the torment of martyrdom suffered by the Imams, and voluntarily submit to physical pain in order to sympathize with them. Yet Sunnis, too, respect the martyrs. Also, Shi'ites might combine the five daily prayers into three or four, if they work long hours, but this does not necessarily indicate a lesser amount of devotion. Since their respective country's government does not always distribute funds in a way Shi'ites agree with, they might pay their zakat (a form of alms or tithing) directly to the poor, while Sunnis pay to the state. It's largely apocryphal that Shi'ites promote a temporary marriage known as muttah for men travelling far from home, as this would run counter to the obligation of chastity.
The line of Imams did not "die out" as this article states. Shi'as believe that the 12th Imam is still alive and will arrive at the Day of Judgment.
As for the sunni/shi'a marriage question, I'd suggest not to do it because I have firsthand experience of what it is like to grow up in a divided household. The decision is ultimately yours, though.
- anon42907
9
Sunnism is more so an exoteric religion. Shiaism is more esoteric. Sunnis worship and copycat Mohammed's physical ways such as when and how he prayed, though the Q'uran doesn't recognize it as law. Shias follow spiritual guidance given by imams succeeding Mohammed and recognize. Both use the Q'uran as a foundation for princples. Faith extracted from the Q'uran is called Islam. However, interpretation of its meanings are debated and thus, further ingrains the division. Both Sunnis and Shias however are traitors to the faith of Islam because Islam means 'peace' and there was no intention for division. There is no way to create division and have peace at the same time. The very separation supports non-unity. To be One with all means respecting and allowing another's faith to be as it is (as long as physical harm is not part of it). There should be no titles such as 'Sunni' or 'Shia'. Even within those religions, most individuals subscribe only partly to its obligatory perceptions of Islam. For example, if every Sunni was surveyed as to their beliefs, no two Sunnis would respond the same in every category altogether. Divisions even in general still invalidate for this reason. The bottom line is that Sunnis and Shias, unless are peaceful in every way, shape and form, are not Islamic. This is a truth most will not accept. Religion anyhow was created only as a test by God. Your reaction or response to religion reveals who you are and how close you are to him. Attaching yourself to religion is a mistake in the first place. Religion isn't the word of God. It's the hearsay of God. Always remember that. If you want to reach God truly, love his people equally. Only self-contribution to others is holy.
- anon42787
8
Shiites adhere to the teachings of the 12 Imams. This is because the Imams are seen as the chosen ones. But its not due to their belonging of a particular family, i.e. Muhammad(P.B.U.H.F)'s family, that Shias believe the Imams have been given Imamate.
It is because of their virtue, their "Taqwa", that God selected them to be the leaders of believers.
Yet those who opposed Muhammad and disliked his family, when Ali demanded caliphate from them, they argued that Ali wanted to declare Imamate, after Muhammad's prophethood, to be in the Banu Hashim, Muhammad's tribe. So according to them, the immamate and prophethood must be in different tribes, which is illogical, as its for God to chose his Caliphs on earth, which is evident from verse of Quran, that God made Adam His caliph in the earth, so He would make all the caliphs, and it cant be decided according to tribe or family. They might all be from one family, or from different families. In the case of 12 Imams, God chose them from one family, to test the unbelievers, who were exposed immediately after Muhammad's passing away.
The decline of Sunni caliphate eventually, its corruption and consumption, until its ultimate abolishment after WWI, is proof of the weakness of the system by which anyone, regardless of capability or virtue, could be made into a caliph, even if he goes against the will of God.
- anon36051
7
If a girl is shia syed and a boy is sunni, but not syed and their beliefs are same, is their marriage allowed in Islam??
- harisyaseen
5
Shia runs on imamate, "ruling of the imams chosen by God", whereas Sunni runs on caliphate, "ruling of a caliph, a voted leader, chosen by people".
Shiites believe that their imams are infallible, because they are from the chosen family of Mohammad. So in order to be a leader, you must be of Mohammad's descent. A tenure for life.
Sunnis believe that only Mohammad was infallible, because he was not allowed to go wrong by God, which is evident in many verses and even surahs in Koran where God calls out on Mohammad directly for his mistakes (i.e. the surah 80, Abasa "He Frowned", and the chapter 93, Ad-Dhuha, etc.), and none after him was, is and will ever be infallible, because God will not inspire anyone else after Mohammad in that manner anymore. So everyone is the same, from whichever family they may be descending from.
So according to Sunni, whoever the public believes is up to doing the job, is the leader. A tenure for as long as you serve people right. The moment you fail, you are replaced with someone who can keep the flag of justice up.
- anon29502
2
I have a question. I'm writing an essay on the differences between Shia and Sunni. Could someone please explain more differences?