Is There Instant Replay in Baseball?

Baseball does not use instant replay to review ball or strike calls.
Instant replay is used in baseball.
Article Details
  • Written By: Dan Cavallari
  • Edited By: Bronwyn Harris
  • Last Modified Date: 31 December 2014
  • Copyright Protected:
    Conjecture Corporation
  • Print this Article
Free Widgets for your Site/Blog
Pittsburgh is the only city in which all three of its pro teams wear the same colors--black and gold.  more...

January 25 ,  1945 :  The Battle of the Bulge ended.  more...

American Major League Baseball (MLB) started using instant replay in August of 2008 to review specific types of calls. Before that, instant replay in baseball had only been used on an irregular basis, usually by individual referees who had doubts about their decision. As of 2008, instant replay can be used to verify three types of calls: whether home run balls were fair or foul, whether the a home run ball actually went out of the ball field or not, and whether or not a spectator interfered with the progress of a ball hit in a home run. These are all known as "boundary calls" since they have to do with whether a hit is considered a home run or not.

Three Uses

The History


Instant replay had been used on a sporadic basis since the 1960s, when baseball Commissioner Bowie Kuhn reviewed video of a controversial call in the 1969 World Series. It was used on and off again until 1999, when referees were actually reprimanded by the American League Office for looking at footage of a ball that hit the scoreboard in a game between the Florida Marlins and the St. Louis Cardinals. The Marlins protested, saying that watching the footage set a bad precedent, and the use of instant replay in baseball was banned until the MLB officially sanctioned it in 2008. It was officially used for the first time in the World Series the next year when Yankees player Alex Rodriguez hit a ball that hit a camera.

The Debate

New Developments



You might also Like

Discuss this Article

Post 5

Sporkasia - What you say sounds good, but what happens when we get to the point where every play is being reviewed? Are fans expected to spend 12 hours watching a baseball game. That may be an exaggeration, but the games will get longer.

I think the answer is creating the best umpire school possible and then putting the calls in the hands and in front of the eyes of the people trained and paid to do the job. Let the umpires do their jobs. The fans will let them know when they make bad calls.

Post 4

Drentel, I am a baseball traditionalist, and even I see that instant replay has its merits. What's wrong with taking a few extra minutes to get a call correct. I'd rather have the umpires get the call right--even if it costs my team a victory.

I agree that baseball umpire training has improved, but they are human and they miss calls. Let's help them get it right with a second and third and fourth look when needed.

Post 3

Animandel - That's a good question. From my point of view, the game does not need instant replay. Umpire training has improved over the years, and umpires are now graded. Sure they still make mistakes and get the call wrong, but even instant replay is not perfect.

Instant replay just slows down the game, and it was already slow enough.

Post 2

I am torn: Is instant replay good for baseball? Or, is it going to ruin America's pastime?

Post your comments

Post Anonymously


forgot password?