Is it Better to Hand Wash Dishes or Use a Dishwasher?

home garden

One can hand wash dishes as safely as if one uses a dishwasher. However, the process to safely hand wash dishes is extensive and must always include the "three-bowl" system in order to ensure that all germs have been removed from the dishes.

The three bowl system, or three sink system recommended for when you hand wash dishes is the following:

  • Have three separate sinks or containers.
  • The first should contain water as hot as you can stand, and detergent.
  • The second container should be used to rinse the dishes.
  • The third container should be a mix of water and bleach solution, normally 1.5 teaspoons bleach to a gallon (3.78 L) of water.

Unfortunately for some, adding bleach causes irritation to the skin and mucus membranes when you hand wash dishes in this way. In these cases, one can use water in all three containers that is at least 170 degrees F (76.66 C). The water must maintain this temperature throughout the process, which usually means adding additional hot water as it cools.

This second method to hand wash dishes also has its downfalls. First, this high of temperature can easily burn the hands, and will especially burn the hands of young children, within a matter of seconds. Thus children cannot help with hand washing the dishes in this manner. Second, the time it takes to heat water and monitor temperature in order to hand wash dishes safely may be extensive. For safety purposes, one should have temperature gauges for each of the containers.

Because of the difficult process involved in one being able to properly hand wash dishes, most people feel that the dishwasher is a safer and certainly easier practice. However, some are concerned about certain types of detergent residue left on dishes after they are washed. Some dishwasher detergents contain fairly toxic chemicals, and must be kept out of the reach of children. This begs the question as to whether residual chemicals on dishes could harm children or adults.

If this is a matter of concern to you, you do not necessarily have to hand wash dishes to avoid exposure to chemicals. In fact, virtually any dishwasher detergent will safely sanitize dishes because dishwashers, especially when one uses the drying cycle, employ heat to kill germs.

There are many biodegradable and non-toxic dishwashing detergents on the market. They generally perform as well as those that have more toxic ingredients. These are readily available at natural food stores and markets like Trader Joes. With a nontoxic detergent in hand, you can still employ the faster method of using the dishwasher, instead of the slower method required to hand wash dishes.

Related wiseGEEK articles

Category






  
  
	

		

New: Discuss this Article

Posted by: anon14521
there is a new product out that actually filters the water going into the dishwasher, solving the cloudy, spotty dishes problem for good. parents can also rest assure their children's dishes and bottles are being rinsed with extremely clean filtered water.
Posted by: bigmetal
i remember the three bowl method from home ec--it's definitely a lost art! i do have to say that i'd take scalding hot water and bleach over antibacterial soap anyday. i fear that overuse of antibacterial soap is causing more harm than good, and there is much debate as to whether antibacterial products are creating strains of super-bacteria. it's more of a convenience, and has taken the place of good old fashioned elbow grease. i don't think dishwashers (which are miracles of modern technology!) employ antibacterial soap, but instead, heated water and steam to clean the dishes...
Posted by: hclewk
"However, the process to safely hand wash dishes is extensive and must always include the "three-bowl" system in order to ensure that all germs have been removed from the dishes."

I remember back in the 1850's when millions died from not using the "three-bowl" method. (joking)

Seriously! There is such a thing as antibacterial dish soap. Do you know what the 'antibacterial' part does? It kills germs. No more scalding hot water and bleach.

The only time I ever use hot water is when I want to soften some food stuck on a dish. How many times have I gotten food poisoning from dirty dishes? None. And no, I do not have a dish washer.

And for anyone who does not know this, lack of bacteria can be more harmful in the long run than its presence.

If a tree grows in an area with no wind, and then suddenly a 60MPH wind blows, the tree might fall. But if that same tree were to grow in an area with a constant strong wind, that same 60MPH wind would be laughable.

If you never encounter bacteria, you won't be sick until you come upon even the mildest of diseases. If you encounter bacteria daily, your immune system will fend off minor diseases and only the tough stuff will affect you (and even then to a much lesser degree)

Posted by: somerset
For centuries dishes were washed by hands, it appears quite safely. It is good to wash dishes immediately after a meal though, so bacteria have no time to grow. Once the dishes have been washed and dried, there is little chance that something unwanted will grow on a them.

When I have only a few dishes to wash, I might wash them by hand, but on the whole I prefer to use the dishwasher. I rinse the dish first in the sink, then place it in the dishwasher and wash when dishwasher is full, but at least once a day even if not completely full. I think that both methods are quite safe.


FREE: Subscribe to wiseGEEK

 
    learn more

our strict privacy policy ensures that your email address will be safe



Written by Tricia Ellis-Christensen

copyright © 2003 - 2008
conjecture corporation